From Leonard Erickson · 1996-04-10 20:35 · #73167 in FREE25
In reply to NET_DEV by Jason Steck
-=> Quoting Jason Steck to Leonard Erickson <=- LE> That's the main reason FTS-1 has hung on. Neither FTS-6 nor EMSI are LE> "inter-operable". JS> Even if I were to agree with your argument, that doesn't change the JS> fact that it is essentially a POLITICAL "need" for FTS-0001. JS> Basically, another network (non Fidonet) could freely require EMSI as JS> its "base" standard. The overall TECHNOLOGY should not be constrained JS> by the POLITICAL decisions of Fidonet. The decision as to what the "base" technology is is a *technical* decision. If I decide to use Arcnet, Token ring, 10-base-2, 10-base-T, or whatever, that decision is a *technical* decision. It's perfectly possible to make a technical decision for political *reasons*, but that doesn't change the fact thast the decision is *technical*. JS> Fidonet, for better or worse, has chosen to wed to the XModem-based JS> FTS-0001 standard as its "base" level. Now why should other networks JS> be required to remain stuck with Fidonet if they don't want to? Who says that they have to? The *only* reason most networks using "fidonet technology" stick to the various fido tech standards is because the available *software* does. And because most of the members belong to fido. JS> The basic point is that the technology definition should ONLY define JS> what the various session types are. The decision about which ones JS> should or should not be a "base" is left to the politicos. No. For a network to *be* a network, you have to define the standards used. There has to be a certain amount of inter-operability. For example, while I use uucp, and couldn't do a TCP/IP session to save my life, I *do* follow the RFCs regarding mail and news structures. If I didn't, then even if I *did* use TCP/IP I couldn't be part of Usenet. You *have* to agree on certain things as "base level" standards, or you won't get anywhere. JS> -!- JMail-G 2.80d JS> ! Origin: PROZ Software -- JMail/JMQWK (FIDONET 1:285/424) ... Emulate: (v.) to simulate hardware glitches with software bugs. --- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30 * Origin: Shadowshack (1:105/51)