Slimelite BBS

NET_DEV

Back to FREE25

From Pierre Phaneuf · 1996-04-07 02:35 · #73105 in FREE25

In reply to NET_DEV by David Robins

 DR> Ya, I know, you might break someone's homebrewed Commodore-64-based
 DR> FTS-1 mailer, espescially if you leave out support for 300 baud modems
 DR> ;^).

Yes, I understand this...

 DR> Sounds a little bit socialist, though, and anti-open-architecture.
 DR> Maybe APIs for common programming language, DLLs for Windows/etc., or
 DR> object (.OBJ) files for PCs.  Or some kind of "invented DLL" for DOS
 DR> which contains the required functions and a table of offsets, or
 DR> something like that :-).

Not socialist at all, and really not anti-open-architecture... My personal idea of FTS-1 and FTS-6 are that they are quick throw-together hack. FTS-6 has "room for expansion" in the order of 12 bytes. Unless you can find a "novel" way of compressing 8 AKA's in 12 bytes, this is not exactly what I call open architecture... EMSI on the other hand, has his EMSI_DAT packet, that could be 64k as far as I'm concerned. If I'd get 32-bit protected-mode one day, I could accept something in the order of more than 4000 AKA's. Not that I have any use for 4000 AKA's, the point being that EMSI is *very* tought out and expandable. It has support for additions such as the IDENT field and as space for other. It also work perfectly and seamlessly with systems that don't even have a Fidonet technology address. The DLL idea is not exactly what I had in mind, only a standard that can *take* expansion in every way available.

 PP>> frozen and (as the current Policy have it) nodes are obligated to
 PP>> support FTS-1 to be part of Fidonet, we could change FTS-1 from
 PP>> time to time... Maybe even big changes, just don't change at a
 PP>> whim and give something like a 6 month or more notice to
 PP>> developers to tell them "soon, it will be different and you
 PP>> support it or you're out"...

 DR> Good idea.

Slowly going to FTS-6 would be nice... Not too big a change, as most FTS-1 mailer also are FTS-6 compatible and adding FTS-6 compatibility to an FTS-1 mailer isn't too difficult...

 DR> Good idea, drop the FTS-1 people... who needs 'em anyways, better to
 DR> keep the 100 or so 28.8/EMSI people who are sick and tired of fido's
 DR> ancient specs. and want to move on (to internet etc. if fido won't
 DR> suffice).

I'm not talking about 28.8/EMSI people... FTS-1 is not a widely *used* standard anyway, at least, it's what I think... Could someone tell me what mailers in existence that *only* support FTS-1? Going to FTS-6 as a standard would not be such a big change, and there is Bink 2.50 that have it's code freely available and compilable and portable to many systems...

Pierre
phaneuf@absint.login.qc.ca

--- FMail/386 1.02
 * Origin: Zaphod Beeblebrox for President! (1:167/136.14)