From John Passaniti · 1996-04-07 13:04 · #73101 in FREE25
> JP> Ironic that when I talk about the cheap Internet access
>
> Not free.
For a full-service unlimited Internet account, no. However free access to Internet mail and news is already offered here in Rochester. Free access to WWW services (using a text interface) are now available here in Rochester at all the local libraries, or via dial-up for anyone who owns a modem. Graphical access to the WWW goes online by the end of the year, again free for access.
> It is a common model that anytime you want to dial someone
> up, you will generally be able to get mail for free in Fidonet.
> If you are having trouble finding someone who will not charge
> you a single cent for fidonet mail, give me a call, on +61 2
> 436 1785.
>
> I know I'm not the only one in the world who will give you
> a FREE fidonet feed.
Indeed, I have offered that people can call my node and get free access to Fidonet as well as Internet mail and news. I offer this even though it costs me some money. This is the basis of what I am saying. Yes, from the "client" perspective, Fidonet may certainly be free. But from the "server" side, there are costs, and those costs are being absorbed by others. To say that Fidonet is free only looks at Fidonet from the client side, and ignores the costs associated with Fidonet.
> IF YOU WANT mail from other places, of course it needs to
> be paid for. If you want local mail, you can get it for free.
Part of what makes Fidonet interesting is that you can reach people outside your local area. If there are people who only want local mail, fine. But I'm guessing those people make up a tiny minority in Fidonet. Again, in Sydney, your mileage may vary.
> There is no requirement for you to pay for outside mail.
> You can choose to stick with local mail.
True, but it kind of defeats one of the most interesting parts of Fidonet.
> It is if you do it right. I don't know about Rochester, but there is
> enough mail generated by folks in Sydney that if I were to read it
> all, I would not be able to sleep. And then there's people who will
> dial Sydney from other places to pick up Sydney mail FOR THEMSELVES,
> and post replies FOR THEMSELVES, which beefs up the no-cost traffic
> in Sydney even more. You can pretend all you like that fidonet is
> totally dependent on 3 sugar daddies, and the moment they leave, the
> whole of fidonet will cease to exist, but you will be wrong.
I'm not talking about just the backbone. Sugar Daddies exist at all levels in Fidonet.
> BTW, I've forgotten what this discussion was about. Is
> this a prediction of death, or a prediction of mail flow
> stopping or what?
I don't believe Fidonet will ever die. Just as there are people who cling fondly to their CP/M machines, Fidonet will continue to exist for quite some time. Fidonet *is* dying, at least in North America. With Internet connections coming very cheap, it often makes more economic sense to use the Internet than Fidonet. Hell-- many nets (including ours) uses the Internet as the transport for our Fidonet mail. And that is the trend-- here. In places where Internet access is still expensive, I expect Fidonet will last much longer.
Saying Fidonet is free as you are presumes people are content to stick with local content, and/or they use the services of someone else who pays for it. You can rightly say that local traffic is free, but you can't say your reading this paragraph is free. You may not have paid anything to access it, and the node you connect to may not have paid, but somewhere along the chain, some node paid so that you could read this text.
--- GEcho 1.00
* Origin: Christian? God demands you kill me. Write for details! (1:2613/102)