Slimelite BBS

A not so hypothetical question

Back to FREE25

From Paul Edwards · 1996-04-06 04:37 · #73081 in FREE25

 * Crossposted in area ZONE3_SYSOP, NET_DEV

r> Firstly, please understand that this thread is fast becoming very 
r> frustrating.

I just noticed this thread, and first of all, I'd like to say that
your radio system sounds very interesting from a technical viewpoint.
However, you may consider most of my message political, I don't know,
I haven't written it yet.

ag> i can't see why one couldn't use a point address for the second

That would certainly seem like an obvious thing to do.  If the
second system was not up during ZMH, then it basically doesn't
qualify to get into the Fidonet nodelist, unless you want to apply
for an exemption to that rule, in which case you need to demonstrate
that you are of a significant benefit to fidonet as a whole.  If you
want to go this last route, this is something which is completely
between you and your NC.

However, I understand that you wish to get in under the rule that
you ARE directly contactable during ZMH.

However, you are WRONG.  During ZMH you must support FTS-1, which 
has no concept of AKA's.  So if you don't present the address you
have in the nodelist when someone calls you, you are not eligible
to be in the nodelist!

r> The software I will be running doesn't support *obsolete* fakenet 
r> addressing.

What software are you running?  You might be able to get Tobruk to
work for you.  I'm not sure how it will deal with sending mail
from a point to another point.

r> Obviously fidonet does not wish to move on. New technologies are being 
r> developed (although what I will be using is more unusual rather than "new"), 
r> and these days there is far much more than the public switched telephone 
r> network.

Which is an interesting point, contactable via radio seems like a 
good idea.  But then, you can also say that being contactable via
the internet, means that everyone with an internet account can apply
for fidonet listing.

Which really begs the question, what's the point of fidonet nodelisting?
Isn't it a list of people contactable during ZMH via the PSTN?

r> I seriously doubt that FTS-5 will be updated in a hurry to allow connection 
r> methods which do not use the phone system, and I seriously doubt that policy 
r> will be updated in a hurry. Therefore, it seems that I am just wasting my 
r> time.

Just today, a message came in to NET_DEV from Jason Steck about
"Omninet", which seems to be what you are suggesting.  I don't know
exactly what Omninet is designed to cover, but it would seem that
the Internet is one way of contacting someone, snail mail is another,
crashmail during ZMH in fidonet is another.  Surely the fidonet 
nodelist is for the purpose just stated?

r> You'll be happy to know I have bitten the bullet and a new PHONE line will 
r> be installed next week. So much for progress.

Actually, I think you stated the REAL problem yourself.  You are
running software which doesn't support fakenet etc properly.  The
progress should be made in the software technology, which is under
your control, rather than getting the nodelist to fit you.

r> I continue to stand by fidonet as people flock to the internet, but I can 
r> see that if things do not (or are not able to) change to adapt to new 
r> circumstances and ideas, the network will stagnate.

So write the software which will allow you to achieve the result you
want.  Or modify Tobruk (assuming it needs modification).  Gating
software may also achieve what you want.

Can you answer this:
What is the problem of the fidonet nodelist containing just a list
of people contactable via FTS-1 during ZMH on the PSTN?

There is NOTHING ANYWHERE that says that the fidonet nodelist is the
one governing body in the entire universe.

r> To throw some fuel in the fire: what happens when cable modems become 
r> available within the next couple of years. Will those using them be refused 
r> a nodelisting if they are not dialable by the PSTN, as you have refused me 
r> one?

Quite possibly.  In fact, a case could be made that the fidonet
nodelist should only contain people contactable via V22.  I have
seen HST-only nodes before!!!  ie uncontactable for practical
purposes.

I think what's really needed is better software to do what you really
want.  How about outlining your needs in NET_DEV?  I will crosspost
this message there.  BFN.  Paul.

P.S. For NET_DEV info, Rowan has two systems, located in different
locations (2km apart), which are connected via a serial radio link,
and wishes to have both systems nodelisted to the same phone number,
so that both systems can provide mail to other points and other
nodes.

---
 * Origin: X (3:711/934.9)