Slimelite BBS

Re: An political question

Back to FREE25

From HECTOR SANTOS · 1996-04-05 08:26 · #73066 in FREE25

In reply to Re: An political question by Michael Chamberlain

MC> Especially since the MSGID is not intended for addressing of any sort.

Your argument breaks down with that statement.

HS>> Coincidence?  It works EACH and EVERY TIME. No coincidence.

MC> OK, then. Think of a series of messages where the MSGID address is a
MC> Fidonet address.

Nearly 99% of the time and that is the POINT. Whatever it is, it is
unique to the individual or the originating system, be it a internet,
fidonet, CompuServe Address, telephone, whatever.

MC> If I use the MSGID address as a Fidonet format reply address, it works
MC> EACH and EVERY time.

Just like I said it would. So why not the REPLY?  Where does it say
in the specs "By the way, don't rely on the REPLY address"?

MC> Therefore, people who put non-Fidonet addresses
MC> in MSGIDs are obviously wrong, because it doesn't work with my
MC> implementation.

Again, your argument breaks down with that statement <g>  The format of
the address is the the issue in this debate.

MC> The only reason you have offered to "prove" that everybody else in the
MC> world is doing it incorrectly and you're doing it correctly is that if
MC> people don't do it your way, your software breaks. Not very convincing.

On the contrary, I look at the end-result. If you do a follow up and the
address is not pointing to the right entity, it is wrong.  If my SX
software is doing the same thing, then it WRONG too.

MC> Your justification is that addressing is more important than
MC> threading. This is beside the point. The MSGID/REPLY kludges are
MC> designed for reply threading.....

and MESSAGE IDENTIFICATION which means it allows ONE to IDENTIFY, FIND
and WRITE to the individual who WROTE the message.

later
--- Platinum Xpress/386/Wildcat! v1.2j
 * Origin: Xpress Tech Support BBS * 305-248-7815 (1:135/382)