Slimelite BBS

FTSCD

Back to FREE25

From HECTOR SANTOS · 1996-04-05 07:26 · #73063 in FREE25

Hello Jan!

In a message to Hector Santos <04/02/96> Jan N. Klug wrote:

JN> hi HECTOR!

PP>>> P.S.: YET another message that the REPLY kludge doesn't work for
PP>>> addressing.
HS>> Well, all you are doing is PROVING my case!  It doesn't work because
HS>> YOUR SOFTWARE SCREWED IT UP!

JN> it doesn't work because it was not designed to do so...

But where does it say that in the specs?  Where does it say that the
address field should not be consider "reliable", hence unusable?

This is what I have trouble with, with 99% of the mail out there, 99% of
them are generated as normal replies.  You replying to me and I replying
to you, the next guy replying to me or you, etc, and each and every
case, the "ADDRESSING" is maitained.  It points to the "entity" or
participants or originating system involved in the conversation.

So the question is, why would a "Follow Up" screw up this perfect
integrity of the mail system which from then on end, negates the
functionality of one being to communication with an original party?

FTS-9 in my opinion is as it is because the AUTHOR saw a great system
that works before for ADDRSSING and for THREADING. It works 100% for a
normal reply system which is FOUND on MOST BBS systems.  Most BBS
systems do not have a "Forwarding" concept and if they do, its usually
reserved for the "SYSOP" only.  Most people, before they added logic to
do a natural follow up, did so by doing a NORMAL reply but then changing
the "TO FIELD" of the reply which in effect, is a "follow up".

In my strong opinion, I don't he considered a FOLLOW up situation
because I do not think he would simply say "Well addressing is not part
of the spec and this is simply for threading".  It simply doesn't make
sense, and finally, it simply doesn't any more sense to continue this
philosophy with the thinking that threading (JAM or otherwise) is more
important and addressing in FidoNet.

Anyway, I am getting tired of this too and I am going to drop this
matter. Chalk it up as just another "stupid" issue of Fidonet.
--- Platinum Xpress/386/Wildcat! v1.2j
 * Origin: Xpress Tech Support BBS * 305-248-7815 (1:135/382)