From Pierre Phaneuf · 1996-04-03 17:41 · #73029 in FREE25
HS> But its only becomes UNGUARANTEED during the rare "follow up"
HS> situation.
And how to you recognise such a message from ordinary replies? If you find such a algorithm, I agree we could use the REPLY address for addressing, since we'd know when it would be right or not. But, since I'm not as brilliant as you, I don't have any such algorithm.
HS> The people that should be involved are, Jim Nutt, and all email editor
HS> authors, including myself, Peter Stewart and Joho, both that i know
HS> lurk around here and read all related mail. I know peter does <g> Why
HS> don't they jump in?
In fact, when I'll see Joho gets into this, I think I'll stop adding to this thread, since I'll only have to lay back and watch...
PP>> Answer this question: Is FTS-9 more for message reply linking
PP>> or addressing?
HS> Without a doubt, uncategorically, undenyably, ADDRESSING is more
HS> information and have more practice use for MOST applications and users
HS> than threading. Absolutely, positively more important as far as ADD
HS> VALUE to the system. Threading DOES NOT WORK for everyone and is very
HS> rare among the MAJORITY of applications and users, especially OFF-LINE
HS> users. On the other hand, ADDRESSING plays a more important form in
HS> terms of PERSONAL REPLYING to participants of a given message.
You missed to question. I was not asking which is more important, I was asking what FTS-9 has been made for. If threading doesn't work for you, them sorry, it work's for me and a lot of other sysops. Ask any Usenet zealot about the importance of threading, and considering the mass of mail they have to wade through these days, an avid Usenet users is a user to listen to for features they'd like.
PP>> REPLY addresses does not point to person, but to messages. Read
PP>> this phrase again.
HS> Where does it say in FTS-9 that addressing is not important? Where
HS> does it say that REPLY does not POINT to a PERSON? Many authors and
HS> people in the industry will equate a PERSON to a ADDRESS. Who are you
HS> talking to? Ether?
=== Begin ===
The origaddr and serialno fields must be identical to the
corresponding fields in the MSGID of the message to which this
message is a reply. A REPLY line is never generated in a
message that is a reply to a message that does not contain a
MSGID line.
=== End ===
Must point to the MSGID of the message to which this message is a reply. Excerpt from FTS-9. I'm sending this message into the NET_DEV echo, but I just want to have this message tick off the personal mail feature of your reader... I'm not sending it to you. If I were, I would have sent it via netmail.
HS> You are TALKING to a PERSON, if you were NOT talking to a PERSON,
HS> then why not simply CHANGE the NAME to someone else and see how far
HS> you get in communications. This is not A NEWSGROUP where all mail is
HS> sent to ALL!
Yes, but the threading kludge point to the message that is being replied to. When I use the reply to other person feature, I'm still replying, and that's why it's correct to have REPLY address different than the address of the person I'm writing to. I want it to point to the message I was reading when I pressed the key to reply.
Pierre
phaneuf@absint.login.qc.ca
--- FMail/386 1.02
* Origin: Zaphod Beeblebrox for President! (1:167/136.14)