Slimelite BBS

Re: A not so hypothetical question

Back to FREE25

From Leonard Erickson · 1996-04-09 10:43 · #73025 in FREE25

-=> Quoting Paul Edwards to rowan_crowe <=-

 PE> Quite possibly.  In fact, a case could be made that the fidonet
 PE> nodelist should only contain people contactable via V22.  I have
 PE> seen HST-only nodes before!!!  ie uncontactable for practical
 PE> purposes.

To the best of my knowledge, when this has come up in Zone 1, the
ruling has been that you have to be available at all the *lower* rates
your modem supports.

So with an HST, you had better accept mailer connections at 300, 1200,
and 2400. If not, you lose your node number. Due to the lack of "real"
300 bps systems in the nodelist, I don't know of a case where somone
has gone after a Zyxel node because it can't be reached at 300 (seems
that Zyxel misidentifies a 300 carrier as FAX). My opinion is that if
it came up, they'd have to either forbid Zyxels (not likely) or forbid
300 bps systems (not exactly a hardship these days :-)

If a 1200 or 2400 mailer call gets *rejected* by the mailer of an HST
(or V32, or...) system for being too slow, then a PC *should* be filed,
and I'm fairly confident that the filer would win.

 PE> P.S. For NET_DEV info, Rowan has two systems, located in different
 PE> locations (2km apart), which are connected via a serial radio link,
 PE> and wishes to have both systems nodelisted to the same phone number,
 PE> so that both systems can provide mail to other points and other
 PE> nodes.

Since any attempt to call either system would go to the one at the
nodelisted number, I don't see any *reason* for the other system to be
nodelisted. It doesn't give any advantages to anyone. Either I'm
missing something, or he's got nothing to complain about.

If I have serval systems linked by a LAN, then they are for all
practical purposes one *big* system. I can list them one of two ways. I
can list the number for one system, and let it handle all the mail. Or
I can list several of them, each at their own phone number, and handle
any routing internally. 

If I chose the first case, I can have *all* the systems making outgoing
calls and identifying themselves as the listed node. There are several
local sysops who do exactly that. 

If I do the second, then I either have to support akas, or I must have
the systems identify with the proper ID (at least to *incoming* calls).

So where's the problem?

... Sysops Law: Trial and error is still faster than .DOC.
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30
 * Origin: Shadowshack (1:105/51)