Slimelite BBS

Re: NET_DEV

Back to FREE25

From Leonard Erickson · 1996-04-05 05:04 · #73011 in FREE25

In reply to NET_DEV by Jason Steck

-=> Quoting Jason Steck to Pierre Phaneuf <=-

 JS> This is exactly the kind of direction I was going in -- instead of
 JS> "mandating" the old FTS-0001 XModem session, the technology end of
 JS> things should only document an open-ended session negotiation method
 JS> (such as EMSI supplemented by certain information contained in a new
 JS> nodelist)  which would allow systems to negotiate from among a range
 JS> of standards. 

I think you are mising the point here. The reason FTS-1 is "mandated"
is quite simple and has little to do with any "vocal minorities". 

It is required so that regardless of what *else* systems may support,
they will always have at least *that* as a common protocol. Any
workable network that includes the idea that any node should be able to
connect "directly" to any other node *has* to mandate support of some
*one* item, so as to ensure that there is a common protocol in *any*
possible connection.

Negotiating from a range of standards is fine. And EMSI does allow
this. But if you *don't* require that everyone support a particular one
of those standards, then what happens when two systems try to negoiate
but don't have any standards in common?

That's the main reason FTS-1 has hung on. Neither FTS-6 nor EMSI are
"inter-operable". So if I'm running FTS-6 and you are running EMSI with
no FTS-6 support, we can't communicate. So to get rid of FTS-1, they'd
have to *require* support of *either* FTS-6 or of EMSI. And that
results in complaints from two vocal *majorities*. (well not *really*
majorities, but I daresay each side would number 35-45% of Fidonet)

The continuing support for "obsolete" systems is more of a bonus "side
effect". 

You can't have a network without some sort of minimal standard of
compatability. For Fido, it's FTS-1. For the Internet it's RFC-820(?)
and RFC-1036 (mail and news specs).




... Emergency repair procedure #1: Kick it.
--- Blue Wave/DOS v2.30
 * Origin: Shadowshack (1:105/51)