Slimelite BBS

Re: orig MSGID -> new REPLY

Back to FREE25

From HECTOR SANTOS · 1996-03-31 21:32 · #72982 in FREE25

In reply to Orig Msgid -> new Reply by HECTOR SANTOS

II> A simple sequential counter is far more effective and, computationally,
II> exceedingly "cheap". All FidoNet's developers (are there any left?)
II> need to do is to take a simple counter _in_combination_with_ the
II> originating node number to uniquely identify any message.

IT WON'T WORK!!!!!! Do you know that word "WORK"?

II> The points I've raised above have been raised (in here) for (literally)
II> years by me and others yet no-one's seen the sense in it .. <sigh> ..

Because it doesn't make sense and NEVER WILL MAKE SENSE!! <sigh sigh
sigh all you want>

I think what you are failing to SEE is that YOU are not considering
"Networks and Echos" and the introduction of other applications into the
picture.   For the sake of simplicity, lets say your "serial #" is 1, it
is entirely possible to have a serial number #1 in ECHO X and in ECHO Y?
Are they they same message?   How do you handle cross posting?  And if
you want to keep threading is "ECHO" a factor in the thread?

In summary, a 32-CRC of the following is among the BEST you will be able
to do in FidoNet:

             To+From+Subject+Date+EchoTag

The odds are EXTREMELY better than your incremential serialization and
in the END RESULT, in practical terms, more applications can work in
harmony and independent of any "commonly stored seed number" factor.
--- Platinum Xpress/386/Wildcat! v1.2j
 * Origin: Xpress Tech Support BBS * 305-248-7815 (1:135/382)