From Joseph Kelleher · 1996-04-12 04:49 · #72571 in NEWMUSIC
(Page 1/2) SJ> [The 80s] SJ> A *few* gems? This is confusing.. Personally, there are hundreds SJ> of these gems, and they're just the ones I've heard.. Well perhaps, but in general I find what has been of the 90s so far has been much more ready to provide some good stuff than most of the 80s was. You could say that much of 90s music has its roots in the 1980s, but that doesn't mean that there was anything good about the 80s as an era in itself. SJ> And I've NEVER been told what to like.. I'll leave that to Oasis SJ> fans.. Don't be controversial, it's not nice :-) SJ> What, the 60's? NOT FOR ME.. The 60's were just a more rebellious SJ> 50's So? It was much better than the 50s. You can say that the 60s music had its roots in the 50s just like you can say that 90s music has its roots in the 80s, but that doesn't mean the 50s and 80s were better than the 60s and 90s, they were worse. While good music was taking hold, it was greatly diluted with crap. It was only in the decade following such originality that the benefits could be reaped. BTW, what would 50s music consist of? SJ> The music I listen to owes NOTHING to the 60's. Perhaps not. But if it owes something to the 80s, that doesn't make the 80s a good era in their own right. Unless you are listening to (lesser known) 80s material. SJ> The success of genres has little to do with record sales and it SJ> being the 'in' thing, and artistically, it usually has a detrimental SJ> effect. It's tempting to think the variety that can be enjoyed these days is because there is a diminishing concept of the 'in' thing. More people have now got their ears to the ground and so more artists can enjoy small but real successes, resulting in more music. SJ> What's happened in the 90s is that these styles have been SJ> commercialised, bastardised, mutated and disfigured. Changed and developed - crap will always surface where there is music, but the commercialisation etc. of some styles is not a bad thing. SJ> If I say to someone I like Techno, they automatically think I am SJ> some kind of 2 Unlimited fan. A classic example of the crap I mention - if someone thinks techno means 2 unlimited, then they are not musically literate, and so I wouldn't talk to them about anything music-related anyway... SJ> Same goes for Hip-Hop. Most people seem to have trouble SJ> understanding the difference between Hip-Hop and Rap, and the media SJ> invented the term 'Trip Hop', their way of differentiating it, which SJ> is just a sick joke. I know what you mean, but FWIW I've never really been into the habit of classifying music anyway. If you wanted to define any set of rules for classifying music, it would always be possbile IMHO to produce good music which would not sit comfortably in any category. Terms should only be used for convenience, not as a guideline when writing music or selecting your preference. SJ> And Indie? How can people call international chart-topping acts SJ> indie? By it's own definition, Indie is alternative, underground, SJ> experimental. The term Indie had come to mean a certain type of music though, and that then became applicable to chart topping acts etc. SJ> The likes of Oasis are definitely not indie any more, they're SJ> simple pop. I personally wouldn't think I was doing anyone a disservice by calling Oasis "rock", although some people do. There is a definite difference between rock and pop, but most people like to think of rock and pop as the same thing anyway, so it makes no difference. SJ> You mean, why didn't YOU hear of it then? The answer is, because SJ> Mr. and Mrs. Media - the TV, the press, the people who really SJ> control what most people listen to, and what music is in the charts SJ> - thought that at the time, that music was too different, too SJ> spiky. Yep - I can handle that. The media may not have outright control over the state of the music industry, but they can certainly shape it. But it was 80s music culture that put the music industry in the shape it was in, and that is simply not applicable today. Especially now that Take That are no more. For the first time in my life, I could now say that the British music charts are now something I can listen to without thinking how unbelievably sad the >>> continued >>> --- ARCbbs RISC OS [1.64á32c] * Origin: Arcade - The Archimedes BBS in London +44 181 655 4412 (2:254/27)