Slimelite BBS

'Pulse' sources

Back to NEWMUSIC

From KaRMa KiLLeR · 1996-04-09 19:41 · #72306 in NEWMUSIC

On 1 Apr 96, Conor McNally was discussing "'Pulse' sources" with me.

Hi Conor :)

 KK>> The great Pink Floyd has to make some of their records from splicing
 KK>> different performances together. And the album still sounds mostly
 KK>> crap. I think they should hang up their instruments.

 CM> Since the set list changed from gig to gig, then it means they can put
 CM> more on.  I'm glad they did it - if it had been the same as the video
 CM> then there would be no Hey you, astronomy domine or anything...  Sounds
 CM> mostly crap production wise or musician wise ?

IMO, musician wise. Most of the songs on Pulse are pale reflections of the original versions. OK, I understand the difficulties of performing the same stuff night after night on a long hard tour, but at the same time, these are meant to be professionals. If you look at professional classical musicians, they hardly ever have a really bad performance. The reason? They are *real* professionals. I think if you can't cut it live, as near as dammit, like the original, then you're just playing at being a musician.



        \!/
        @-@
 ---ooO-(_)-Ooo---
   KaRMa - KiLLeR



... I'm your No. 1 fan. You're lucky I found you.
--- Spot 1.3a #1413
 * Origin: MUSIC_CONTACTS @ FidoNet (2:441/93.52)