Slimelite BBS

Beatles And Oasis

Back to NEWMUSIC

From Rory Irvine · 1996-04-07 18:13 · #72222 in NEWMUSIC

Hello Tom!

05 Apr 96 11:28, Tom Froggatt wrote to Colin Sergeant:

 CS>> Noel Gallagher although being a great musician will advance this
 CS>> Brit Pop pish into something a lot more decent.

 TF> But Britpop is only pish thanks to him! There really was a movement of
 TF> good British Pop music (Suede, Ash, Echobelly, Sleeper, Elastica, Shed
 TF> Seven etc.) and then the likes of Oasis came along and made it all
 TF> boring :-(.

Yeah.... Oasis songs are all *exactly* the same - boring and unimaginative. How they can be so successful with so many great bands about at the moment is quite beyond me, I'm afraid :(

 CS>> If you listen to the 'B' sides of the singles you here how
 CS>> excellent they sound when not trying to win over the majority of
 CS>> single buyers with these songs which could be a lot better.

 TF> But they're hardly ground breaking! I never said that there was
 TF> anything wrong with the tunes, but the lyrics are hardly intelligent,
 TF> and it's /all/ been done before.

Their B-sides *are* usually better - but then, B-sides are never as serious, and are usually tacked on because they weren't quite good enough for the album. If I find myself preferring their supposedly 'inferior' songs then I *know* that the band is crap :)

 CS>> Mainly youngsters who don't fully appreciate music buy these
 CS>> singles so this is the market which is aimed at.

 TF> I'm sorry, but I can't see the band changing direction at all. I think
 TF> Noel Gallagher was right that they'd be finished after 3 albums - and
 TF> they won't have left any impression on the history of pop.

The hype *will* backfire. Look at the Blur-backlash - and they didn't hype themselves anywhere near as much :)


-Rory

--- FMail/386 0.98
 * Origin:  Rory's shack... (2:443/13.27)