From Neil Atkinson · 1996-04-13 17:21 · #71770 in INTERNAT_UK
In reply to Re: Comments by Richard Halsall
-=> Quoting Tony Rigby to Neil Atkinson <=- NA> Posting netmails into a public echo disrupts the echo and a protracted NA> debate usually occurs mostly off-topic....erm like this ;( I would have prefered this to come via netmail, AFAIK the Mod has asked for this to be dropped, if I am mistaken I am sure he will inform me. I will answer this message via the echo but must ask that anyone else who wants to be involved in this thread do so via NETMAIL.... TR> This surely is a legitimate matter for discussion and I would have TR> thought that this particular echo is the appropriate place for that TR> discussion. Why do you think this echo is the suitable place ? Whether is is legit or not is not for me to say. We could always read the rules and see if a special clause has been added that does allow discussion on xposted netmails....In short what the Mod says is law in this 'ere echo. But out of interest why would you want to read netmail that is intended for someone and xposted without consulting the sender...and would you think it appropriate if it happened to you ? NA> My own view on making netmail public is in total agreement with policy4. TR> Does POLICY4 say that? I haven't read it for a while: can you remind TR> me, please? I didn't quote or paraphrase any of P4 I said I agreed with it on this subject then I added a little missive of my own. You are the second person to pick this up...The problem may be in my poor use of the English language. Well Double-Duth is my native language...:) I won't quote any P4, if you want to debate this point do your own research.... lazy sod :^) NA> the recent Character Assassination thread, what was all that about ? NA> This is another example of netmail problems been dragged into the echo, TR> I don't know. It certainly looked interesting, but I haven't got a TR> clue what it was really about. My point exactly, what was the point in the original message at all, we were all left wondering... "Eh!!!.. Whats all this about". Regards Neil --- * Origin: Nightline BBS +44-(0)1924-452709 Dewsbury,UK (2:250/349)