Slimelite BBS

Re: Comments

Back to INTERNAT_UK

From Neil Atkinson · 1996-04-09 19:12 · #71704 in INTERNAT_UK

In reply to Re: Comments by Neil Atkinson

 -=> Quoting Robert Smith to Neil Atkinson <=-


 RS> off-topic debate suddenly stopped isn't clear, but I would guess that
 RS> most of the MNL's would go bankrupt real quick. 

 Couldn't careless about the MNLs to be honest.
 
 RS> Actually in the *vast* majority of cases, it's entirely appropriate.
 RS> Usually a xposted netmail is from someone outside the echo who has
 RS> written to someone in the echo (probably the mod) with information
 RS> that the echo as a whole would find interesting or useful. 

 Yeah right,..... what colour is the sky in your world....
  
 NA> The poster of the netmail could be guilty of annoying behaviour and
 NA> not the original sender of the netmail.........
 RS> Seeing as the poster is not a sysop, and posts to echomail aren't
 RS> covered by the annoying behaviour regulations, it's hard to see how an
 RS> XAB case could be used here. 

 I wasn't actually taking about XAB, I was talking about annoying
 behaviour fullstop..... you are mistaking excessively annoying
 behaviour with just plain old annoying behaviour....
 Please don't roll out answers to statements that *haven't* been made..
 Your read things that aren't there....
 
 NA> Recent events would seem to prove this, when asked for comments about
 NA> the said netmail the majority of people ignored the contents of the
 NA> netmail
 RS> This is, of course exactly the right response to an inappropriate
 RS> post in an echo.

So how come you have just spent all this bandwidth defending it then ;)

-CUT-

 RS> The experienced user will also know
 RS> that a carefully worded, helpful, netmail to the offending poster can

 Why do you think a user would think there is a problem if the *vast*
 amount of xposted netmails are 'appropriate' to the echo ?
 
 RS> be used to make them aware of the problem without inflaming to whole
 RS> echo in an irrelevant discussion. 
 NA>  and asked the poster not to publish personel netmail into an echo.

Hmm, didn't I say something like that earlier, you remember you spent
an entire paragraph debunking my opinion, now you seem to be of the
same opinion...
So where does the '*vast* majority' of xposted netmails fit in with this
"irrelevant discussion". ?

 RS> Whereas there seem to be a lot of idiots around here who saw this as
 RS> an opportunity to post self-righteous - or even abusive - messages, in
 RS> the guise of 'advice' about using an echo, in order to 'punish' the
 RS> poster for their 'crime'. 

 I saw no such postings in the echo, but what happens in netmail
 is no concern of mine or yours...
 I think you do a great dis-service to the users of this echo making
 false statements like that. Name the people who posted these abusive
 messages into the echo....Please, I would be very interested to know
 who these 'idiots' are.

 RS> An experienced user would realise that such comments are likely to
 RS> cause great distress to a user who's new to Fido and the sometimes
 RS> rather rowdy comments that echomail tends to generate. And thate they
 RS> might even be left feeling that their presence in the echo is no
 RS> longer wanted. 

I seem to have the opposite view (surprise) on this, I thought everyone
in the echo conducted themselves very well...and with good manners....
You think the people who replied to the xpost idiots, I think your
imagination is running away with you....

 RS> He would therefore adopt a more moderate tone in addressing a new
 RS> user who has made a mistake in any echo - or addressing any user in an
 RS> echo that attracts a lot of new users who are looking at Fido for the
 RS> first time. 

I think you are confused with what actually happened and what you
_thought_ had happened...they seem to be poles apart...
I thought everyone was leaning over backwards not to be aggresive in the
nature of their replies......

 NA> My own view on making netmail public is in total agreement with
 NA> policy4. People really should not bring their netmail problems into an
 NA> echo,
 RS> Could you quote the relevant paragraph from P4 please? Seeing as the
 RS> word 'echomail' does not appear in that document, this seems a rather
 RS> strange interpretation. 

Read the quote again please.....
I said I agreed with Policy4 on this subject, then came the period mark.
I then *added my own view on a more specific point.....
Now the problem just may be that you have a different P4 to me but just
in case they are the same check out SECTION 9-9 ...

My interpretation of P4 is my problem
Your problem is that you don't read my messages properly.
You jump off at some tangent trying to refute statements that *have_not*
been made....Don't just look at the words READ and digest them.
Your opinion on xposted netmail changed half way through your message,
maybe you found it a little too hard to defend.

 NA>  the recent Character Assassination thread, what was all that
 NA> about ?

 RS> It was about a user in this echo who was sending netmail messages to
 RS> some of the other users of this echo in an attempt to assassinate the
 RS> character of another user of this echo. 

Half a story, ya see. People have this 'thing' about wanting to make
things public but they don't come out and tell the full story...
They have this overwhelming desire to involve the users of the echo
into their netmail disputes.

WHY ?
Reply via the echo if you want but I notice all other threads on this
subject have gone to netmail...You do as you see fit, but if I comment
further on this it will be via netmail.

Regards
Neil


---
 * Origin: Nightline BBS +44-(0)1924-452709 Dewsbury,UK (2:250/349)