Slimelite BBS

Comments

Back to INTERNAT_UK

From Robert Smith · 1996-04-05 16:30 · #71676 in INTERNAT_UK

In reply to Re: Comments by Neil Atkinson

Hello Neil.

 RS>> rather than sent a netmail. It seems quite valid for ANYONE to
 RS>> reverse that decision if they feels a public discussion would be
 RS>> more appropriate.

 NA> [Names changed to protect the innocent]

 NA> Totally disagree with that statement... Posting netmails into a
 NA> public echo disrupts the echo and a protracted
 NA> debate usually occurs mostly off-topic....erm like this ;(

 Quite what would happen to the echomail system if all the protracted off-topic debate suddenly stopped isn't clear, but I would guess that most of the MNL's would go bankrupt real quick.

 NA> It really doesn't matter if the receiver of the netmail feels public
 NA> discussion would be appropriate, in most case's it probably is NOT.

 Actually in the *vast* majority of cases, it's entirely appropriate. Usually a xposted netmail is from someone outside the echo who has written to someone in the echo (probably the mod) with information that the echo as a whole would find interesting or useful.

 NA> The poster of the netmail could be guilty of annoying behaviour and
 NA> not the original sender of the netmail.........

 Seeing as the poster is not a sysop, and posts to echomail aren't covered by the annoying behaviour regulations, it's hard to see how an XAB case could be used here.

 NA> Recent events would seem to prove this, when asked for comments about
 NA> the said netmail the majority of people ignored the contents of the
 NA> netmail

 This is, of course exactly the right response to an inappropriate post in an echo. Experienced echo users will immediately realise that this is a trivial mistake made by a new user and that the moderator of the echo will be discussing the matter with the poster in order to prevent a repeat of the incident. The experienced user will also know that a carefully worded, helpful, netmail to the offending poster can be used to make them aware of the problem without inflaming to whole echo in an irrelevant discussion.

 NA>  and asked the poster not to publish personel netmail into an echo.

 Whereas there seem to be a lot of idiots around here who saw this as an opportunity to post self-righteous - or even abusive - messages, in the guise of 'advice' about using an echo, in order to 'punish' the poster for their 'crime'.

 An experienced user would realise that such comments are likely to cause great distress to a user who's new to Fido and the sometimes rather rowdy comments that echomail tends to generate. And thate they might even be left feeling that their presence in the echo is no longer wanted.

 He would therefore adopt a more moderate tone in addressing a new user who has made a mistake in any echo - or addressing any user in an echo that attracts a lot of new users who are looking at Fido for the first time.

 NA> My own view on making netmail public is in total agreement with
 NA> policy4. People really should not bring their netmail problems into an
 NA> echo,

 Could you quote the relevant paragraph from P4 please? Seeing as the word 'echomail' does not appear in that document, this seems a rather strange interpretation.

 NA>  the recent Character Assassination thread, what was all that
 NA> about ?

 It was about a user in this echo who was sending netmail messages to some of the other users of this echo in an attempt to assassinate the character of another user of this echo.

Robert

--- FMail/386 0.98
 * Origin: Lightning BBS (Cambridge) /|/ 01954 212231 [V.34] (2:2504/100.17)