Slimelite BBS

Comments

Back to INTERNAT_UK

From Robert Smith · 1996-03-31 00:18 · #71635 in INTERNAT_UK

Hello Geoff.

 GB>>>> Yes, you shouldn't cross-post netmails in an echo!
 [Geoff Basset]

 DB>>> Why not?     Desparate Dan

 GB>> Try reading policy 4 etc... apart from that netmail is classed as
 GB>> private mail and should NOT be posted in a public place!
 [Geoff Basset]

 GB> Could you clarify that please. If the Pvt Flag is set then I agree
 GB> it was intended by the originator that the NetMail message was to be
 GB> considered Private.  However, what is the case when the Pvt Flag is
 GB> NOT set?  If ALL NetMail is to be considered Private what is the point
 GB> of the Pvt Flag? Anyone?
 [Geoff Bent] (Anymore GB's want to join this thread?)

 Everyone seems to have completely misunderstood the issues involved in Dorothy's posting of a netmail, which has resulted in a totally trivial issue being blown up out of all proportion. To attempt to clarify:

 'Private' as regarding netmail means that the /system/ is not to send it to anyone other than the addressee (the sysops of the intermediate systems can look at it too). It does not indicate that the message is confidential or impose any restrictions on what the recipient does with it after it's arrived. Just as if you received a letter in the mail - you hope that the Post Office haven't allowed anyone to read it while they've been carrying it, but you're free to post it on a notice board, send it to 'The Sun' or MI5 or whatever.

 The only grounds for criticising Dorothy here is that if the sender had wanted to discuss in public, he would have posted in the echo rather than sent a netmail. It seems quite valid for Dorothy to reverse that decision if she feels a public discussion would be more appropriate.


 Anyway, to get to your question about the Pvt flag, the important thing to note is that the flag is there to tell the /system/ how to handle the message, not to communicate anything *at* *all* between the author and the recipient. The only way for the author to communicate a desire for the netmail to be confidential is to say so in the message text (this would usually be obvious from context, and hopefully no-one would be daft enough to post really confidential matter through Fido anyway).

 In netmail areas, the Pvt flag is assumed - netmail is never passed to anyone other than the addressee regardless of the Pvt setting. In normal echoes (ones that leave the BBS), the PVT flag is stripped by the mail processor - hence those delightful messages that start "I've set the Private flag so no-one else will see..."

 The main reason for doing this is that although Pvt will stop OLR doors and on-line BBS mail readers from seeing the message, it is still passed to all the BBSs and points - and points do not have the same privileges for reading private mail that sysops do. It also saves having to pay to carry messages that no-one can read. (The decision to strip Pvt is taken when the echo is set up, the software does not insist on it, but it's usually the correct setting for distributed echoes (and certainly all Fido echoes)).

 Therefore the only place where Pvt is of any use is in local 'echo' areas. Most BBSs have a few of these, usually for talking to the sysop and general chatter between users of the BBS. Because these areas do not leave the BBS, Pvt will work. If someone posts to 'Geoff Bent' in a local area, everyone gets to see it. If he sets Pvt, however, only the OLR accessing the account titled 'Geoff Bent' will pack it in to the mail and everyone else's will ignore it. As there's no other way into that area, only you, the sender and the sysop can get at that message.

Robert

--- FMail/386 0.98
 * Origin: Lightning BBS (Cambridge) /|/ 01954 212231/1 [V.34] (2:2504/100.17)