From Anthony Brice · 1996-04-02 09:46 · #71351 in UK_OZ
* This message forwarded from area 'Movie Reviews' (MOVIE_REVIEWS)
* Original message dated 01 Apr 96, from James Berardinelli
SGT. BILKO
A film review by James Berardinelli
Copyright 1996 James Berardinelli
RATING (0 TO 10): 3.0
Alternative Scale: *1/2 out of ****
United States, 1996
U.S. Release Date: 3/29/96 (wide)
Running Length: 1:33
MPAA Classification: PG-13 (Profanity, mature themes)
Theatrical Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Cast: Steve Martin, Dan Aykroyd, Phil Hartman, Gleanne Headley,
Daryl Mitchell, Austin Pendleton, Pamela Segall, Chris Rock,
Catherine Silvers, Eric Edwards
Director: Jonathan Lynn
Producer: Brian Grazer
Screenplay: Andy Breckman
Cinematography: Peter Sova
Music: Alan Silvestri
U.S. Distributor: Universal Pictures
Watch an old episode of THE PHIL SILVERS SHOW, and you'll recognize
just how bad this new version of SGT. BILKO is. But, regardless of
whether you're a fan of the 1950s series or not, it's doubtful you'll
get more than a few halfhearted chuckles out of this lifeless retread.
As envisioned for the nineties by writer Andy Breckman and director
Jonathan Lynn (MY COUSIN VINNY), this SGT. BILKO should be court-
martialed.
For some reason, Steve Martin, the comic force behind such
delightful films as LA STORY and ROXANNE, has descended into an abyss of
unfunny, unoriginal, and unappetizing motion pictures. His latest
releases -- A SIMPLE TWIST OF FATE, MIXED NUTS, FATHER OF THE BRIDE PART
2, and SGT. BILKO -- have varied in quality from mediocre to downright
awful. It's been a long time since Martin has done something worth
watching, and, with every outing like this, it makes me wonder whether
he's lost the flair he once possessed.
Even though Colonel Hall (Dan Aykroyd) is the commanding officer of
Fort Baxter, the place is really run by Sgt. Bilko (Martin). If there's
a scam afoot, Bilko's inevitably behind it, whether it involves a poker
game, an illegal lottery, or an attempt to worm a free trip to Vegas out
of the army. But Bilko's comfortable position is jeopardized by the
arrival of Major Thorn (Phil Hartman), who has come to evaluate Fort
Baxter's prize technological development: the $70 million hover tank.
When the weapon fails miserably in a public demonstration, Thorn has an
excuse to close down the base as well as stick it to his old nemesis,
Bilko, whose actions once got him posted to Greenland.
Martin's Bilko can boast some of the mannerisms of the Silvers
version, but that's about all the two incarnations have in common.
Silvers was funny; Martin isn't. Silvers drew viewers back week after
week; Martin is likely to make anyone in the audience wish they had
stayed home to watch a rerun on Nickelodeon. Actually, Martin probably
isn't a bad choice for Bilko; it's just that the comic doesn't invest
much genuine energy into his portrayal. Whatever happened to SATURDAY
NIGHT LIVE's "Wild and Crazy Guy"?
Of course, it's unfair to put all the blame for this failure on
Martin's shoulders. The screenplay is an absolute embarrassment. Any
of the worst original TV scripts contained more innovation and humor
than this ninety-minute mixture of bad jokes and regurgitated formulas.
The most clever bit in the whole movie comes as part of the end credits,
when this message appears: "The filmmakers gratefully acknowledge the
total lack of cooperation from the United States Army." That's as good
as it gets.
This movie could be viewed as something of a SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE
alumni show, with Martin, Dan Aykroyd, and Phil Hartman topping the
bill. Both Aykroyd and Hartman play straight men to Martin's clown,
and, as a result, all three are wasted.
Recent movie revivals have done great injustices to old TV shows.
We've had DRAGNET, THE BEVERLY HILLBILLIES, THE FLINTSTONES, and now
SGT. BILKO. The unfortunate thing is that these are just the tip of the
iceberg; many more are envisioned, starting with MCHALE'S NAVY and I
DREAM OF JEANNIE. If SGT. BILKO is any indication of their quality, we
might as well stay home and vegetate in front of the television set.
The experience will be far less disheartening than seeing Hollywood
trash yet another fond memory like it has done here.
- James Berardinelli
e-mail: berardin@bc.cybernex.net
web: http://www.cybernex.net/~berardin (or) http://www2.cybernex.net/~berardin
--- Spot 1.3a #991
* Origin: Stevie no hog that joint, no? (2:254/255.1)