Slimelite BBS

Re: Without Rimmer

Back to IMAGES

From Stuart Porteous · 1996-04-10 04:17 · #71233 in IMAGES

In reply to Re: Without Rimmer by Max Kolombos

Saturday, 6 April 1996 17:10:58, Max Kolombos wrote to Stuart Porteous
Subject: Re: Without Rimmer

 MK> On Monday, 1 April 1996 22:18:41, I heard Stuart Porteous
 MK> saying to Max Kolombos :

 MK> Yeah - like I said, that Last Human is a good sci-fi book, but
 MK> it's useless as a Red Dwarf novel, it may make more sense for another
 MK> series, but the serious lack of comedy is it's sticking point.
I think the comedy actually spoils it. You do quite enjoy the book for a
while until he puts an extract from the TV series in which ruins the whole
feel. And it's always so annoying because knowing the TV series so well,
you can place the extract and see right through Doug's feeble attempt to
disguise the fact that it's just a straight rip-off.

 MK> Anyway, I've had a chance to read a preview copy of 'Backwards',
 MK> Rob's book - and it IS good. You can tell that Rob's the funny part
 MK> of the duo, however his writing is far more sinister and compelling
 MK> than Doug's.
Excellent! How did you manage to come across that? (this is just begging
for a smutty comment. And it got one :o)

 MK> As for Rob Llewellyn - I'm prepared to give him a chance
 MK> writing. Admittedly the Smeg Ups/Outs links were DIRE, I hope he can
 MK> produce the goods with RDVII.
I don't think anybody tried particularly hard with the smeg ups/outs, they
were just semi-worth-buying cash-ins, so I think I can excuse him for
that.
It seems to me though, that series 7 could become seriously Americanised,
aimed at pulling the viewers rather than entertaining the ones it already
has: see extra episodes, new character and appearance of daleks. This
could be the series that gives RD a film, and also marks the end of RD as
we know it (Jim).

 SP>> PS, I've captured your script, and I'll get around to reading
 SP>> it, honest!
 MK> Please mail me with any criticism if you can - I need all the
 MK> feedback I get!
Right you are!

 SP>> PPS, I would post the 'official' release of mine and Steve
 SP>> Clappison's "Illusions" script but it's already been posted a couple
 SP>> of times in unfinished forms. Instead, I think I'll finish another
 SP>> one that's been festering in c:\rd\stu\ for a while..
 MK> Excellent. I look forward to reading them!
I've got a bit stuck with my current script, but it comes to a point when
you just see there's nothing more you can do with it.

 MK> ... Are you by any chance Barbra Bellini?
[growl]

   __
  (_ )__
 (__) ( (_)   stuart.porteous@p95.f666.n2502.z2.fidonet.org

... Bug - The most reliable part of a program.
--- Terminate 3.00
 * Origin: Centurion Point Nine Five (2:2502/666.95)