From Max Kolombos · 1996-04-06 23:11 · #71130 in IMAGES
On 01 Apr 96 20:04:03, I heard Craig Young saying to Max Kolombos :
CY> Those pages are missing at my end. I only gripe cause my name is
CY> mentioned in them :) Craig
You're right - I missed them completely : Here they are...
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.63 SMEG UPS TAPE
- In the Smeg Up for Meltdown (4-6) that was tossed because of the noise
in the air, the print would have been useless anyway because glimpses of
the backstage crewmembers are seen in the background.
*- In the Ten Most Asked Questions List, for Question Nine, Kryten says
that in Thanks For The Memory (2-3), 'Lister tells Rimmer he's had his
appendix out.' Technically this isn't correct, as it is *Rimmer* who
mentions the appendix operation while talking about why his 'fake'
memories (the ones of Lister's that Lister gave to Rimmer) don't tally
with his real memories.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3.67 SMEG OUTS TAPE
- The smeg out from Queeg (2-5) where Rimmer flubs his line 'I'm lucky I
can keep my legs on with you in charge' contains a prior smeg out which
would have made the footage useless anyway. In the line immediately before,
Holly says, 'All right, keep your hair on,' without moving his lips.
- In Question 10, the conversation total statement is wrongly attributed
to Future Echoes (1-2) when in fact it comes from Balance Of Power (1-3).
[El Skutto says: This is actually my fault because I didn't pick up this
error in time for the PIP edition that went to GN for the Smeg Outs.]
- In Question 8, Kryten says that in DNA (4-2) it's mentioned that
Rimmer failed his astronavigation exam 13 times. This statement was
actually made in the episode Justice (4-3), not DNA.
- In Question 6, Kryten says that people who speak Esperanto are referred
to as Esperantinos throughout the first series. The Esperantino/Esperantist
question is only raised in the episode 'Kryten,' which is the first
of Series 2.
- In Question 4, Kryten says that Lister said to Rimmer 'You're
beginning to sound like my Mum.' Lister actually said this to Kryten
(Kryten, 2-1). If we want to be really picky, Kryten also said that
Lister asserts he was abandoned at birth. Lister actually says that he
was six weeks old when abandoned (The Last Day, 3-6).
- In Question 3, Lister says that he did tear out page 61 of Lolita (not
page 60) because he was holding the book upside-down. A quick look at
Marooned (3-2) shows that he was indeed holding the book right side up,
and therefore must have torn out page 60.
- In Question 1, Kryten says that his 'all human cells contain DNA'
statement comes from 'episode four, series two.' This would be Stasis
Leak, and Kryten wasn't even in this. The episode was DNA (4-2) --
Kryten has misread the episode notation for the question as
(episode-series) instead of, correctly, as (series-episode).
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
==============================================================================
4.0 ADDITIONS, CORRECTIONS, OR CONTRIBUTIONS TO PIP
I doubt this list can ever be comprehensive. If you have an
inconsistency, resolution, or other input about the PIP, please address
your e-mail to: damone@ios.com
When you write your e-mail, please contain 'PIP' as the subject line, or
reply to this if this is the USENET posting. E-mail is preferred. Please
limit your contributions to one message a day. Include as much information as
possible about the episode in which the inconsistency occurs, as well as
other episodes you may refer to in your post (i.e. use episode numbers
PLEASE). You may include as much information as you want in that one
message, however.
Do not be offended if I do not write back to you, as my mail volume is
pretty high. If I use anything, you will be included in the
Acknowledgements section. I have gotten better at getting back to
everyone, though, and most likely will reply to all e-mails now. If you
are going to be derogatory and hostile, do not expect a reply, but be
assured you will make my mail filter in record time.
All book/series references are gone. They are too much completely
different entities to be included together. While Grant Naylor may have
forgotten which plot they were working with at the time, this project
will not, and will stay only with series/series contradictions. If any
foolish person wishes to do book/series, I've got some stuff you could
probably use. For those looking for book/book inconsistencies, please see
the Book Plot Inconsistencies Project (BPIP), by El Skutto.
==============================================================================
5.0 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First and foremost to:
*** El Skutto ***
...who pretty much did all of the research and writing for the first
version and got this thing off the ground and hopelessly lost in space.
(Thanks Damone for putting up with my nagging so well -- El Skutto.)
She is also the author of the Book Plot Inconsistencies Project
(BPIP), the Red Dwarf References List (RDRL), and the Red Dwarf Fishlist.
Check them out on an internet near you. And you thought you had too much
free time?
Honorable mention as 'Annoying Aussie Of The Year' goes to:
*** Matt Dawson ***
...who pretty much sent me volumes and volumes of plot errors from all of
the episodes whether I wanted them or not, in a coordinated attempt with
another Aussie (who shall remain nameless) to drive me completely insane.
The 'Iron-Man Awards For HTML Conversion' go to:
*** Michael Nagy ***
*** Dave Williamson ***
*** Friday ***
... who convert all the new versions into HTML format at their wonderful
little web pages and save me more nightmares and heartaches.
BUT...
Without the help of these wonderful people, this never would have been:
(Those bound in stars were dedicated workers for this project, viewing
entire series to find inconsistencies, and helping with the beta-ing of the
PIP.)
Helen Bates
Beorahood
BertGordon
Andrew Blume
Edward Buckley
The Cat
CherStrand
*Cma*
Miffy Coghill
David Coombes
Oliver A. Corrigan
Charles Daniels
Brenda Daverin
Dion
John Doyle
Elliedra
Ben Erickson
Gareth Evans
Vicky Evans
Fraser
Friday
Jackie Fuchs
David L. Gilbert
Theodore Graham
Richard Greene
Eric Haas
Holly 512
*Nick Honeywell*
Steve Howell
Graeme Jefferis
Coran Jones
Paul Jones
JJ Flash
Jonathan Kallay
Kevin
Martin King
Christopher M. Kribs
Chris Kuan
Legion
*Lizbeth*
Bette Llewellyn
Lisa Manekofsky
Ned Martell
Tony Martin
Tom Marwede
Dave McRae
Yossef Mendelssohn
Michael Micallef
Sami Mikhail
Mark Moir
Glen Montgomery
*Craig O'Neil*
Chris Nielsen
Boris Pelakh
James Peterson
Will A. Phillips
Todd Pinarchick
Raz
Jill Rhodes
Jim Richards
Eric Rochkind
Alan Salt
Jeremy Schroeder
Barny Shergold
Nick Sim
Daniel Snyder
Cheryl Strand
Charles Sundt
Eddie Talbut
*Maggie Thomas*
John Tudek
Daniel Vasconcelos
Jamie Watson
Lee Weinert
Dean White
Craig Young
Zanndraa
... and to all I may have missed. Please e-mail me so I may rectify the
error.
... and of course, to Grant Naylor, who really made it all possible (and
who now have a copy of this thing apparently). Not only that, they put
El Skutto and myself in the credits of the 'Smeg Outs' video. To wit:
SPECIAL THANKS TO
DAMONE & EL SKUTTO
FOR PLOT INCONSISTENCIES
INFORMATION
==============================================================================
6.0 CONCLUSION
That's it. Go home.
There are groups of small, yellow fish eating my feet,
Damone.
damone@ios.com
==============================================================================
|\ /| |/ FidoNet : 2:255/101.3
| |ax |\olombos Internet : maxk@rezal.demon.co.uk
... An excellent idea sir, with just two minor drawbacks...
--- -->Lazer +44-117-964-9518<--
* Origin: -->Lazer +44-117-964-9518<-- (2:255/101)