Slimelite BBS

Re: Smoking

Back to DIARIST

From Chris Green · 1996-04-01 08:21 · #70923 in DIARIST

In reply to Smoking by Dave Langridge

 -=> Quoting Simon Woodland to Chris Green <=-

Hello Simon,

 CG> In other words, I don't see why other people should pay for the
 CG> treatment of someone's lung cancer if it can be demonstrated that the
 CG> cancer came about as a direct result of the person exercising their
 CG> right to smoke.

 SW> I dont see why I shouldnt get it when the taxs that are raised on fags
 SW> go to the NHS .

No the taxes go firstly to the Treasury and secondly to the EC; there is
no way that you could say that tax raised from tobacco goes to the NHS;
though in all probability a small proportion would eventually find its
way in that direction. :-)

 SW> Its like saying people who drive shouldnt be able to live because
 SW> the fumes are killing are planet ok you can say the exhausts
 SW> have got cats but it has been proven it produces more of another
 SW> substance which is equaly dangerous to the planet.

Now you come to mention the subject.......:-)

 SW> We are all Accountable for somthing true smoking is bad for you
 SW> but also there are a lot of other things that are to.
 SW> Beef
 SW> Too much Drink
 SW> Cars etc etc so I tell you what lets not treat anybody .

No, lets only treat those people who are economically viable prior to
treatment, and who can reasonably be expected to have a good level of
life after treatment.  (John Major and the Conservatives, Party
Manifesto for the last General election).

Chris

... That which holds the power to heal holds also the power to harm...
--- Blue Wave v2.12
 * Origin: Xstream 44-151-488-0698 V21-V34 [OS2/Max3.00/Md1.02e] (2:250/210)