From Erik V. Petersen · 1996-04-11 03:27 · #70483 in CLUB_AMIGA
Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg contributed to this sometimes
Grimly heated discussion saying:
PHvM > Thanks for writing this, as it made me form my opinion about
PHvM > all this much better.
:-) I'm quite certain, Peter, that this is the chief benefit of
almost any in-depth discussion. We rarely actually get anybody to
change their opinions but we do manage to clarify our own :-) :-).
I see where you're coming from with all the points you raise and
have only some minor nits to pick.
> EVP> In an electronic online conference you may want to equate the
> EVP> moderator with the editor but that's even a bit of a reach...
PHvM > No, you're wrong in this analogy: The online conference is not
PHvM > the reporting of news at all. It's generating the news.
Bingo! You're right!
PHvM > Professional Cyberpress will again get the same structure as
PHvM > the other "press", as it has to deal with the same problems.
And it too will in time become "conventional".
PHvM > ... The log of the conference is like the tape some journalists
PHvM > keep running a whole conference.
PHvM > The journalist decides which parts are reported and how they
PHvM > are reported in the raw news item...
What used to be called the work of a legman.
PHvM > The editor, if there is one, then molds it to fit in the style
PHvM > of the particular news-channel and the available space in it.
PHvM > There is no editor here (Ref. to Haynie Conference --evp) as
PHvM > there is no specific news-channel here.
Can't argue with that logic.
> EVP>>> Now, when Compuserve offers a service involving paid pro-
> EVP>>> fessional production, I shall never argue ownership.
PHvM > No, but that ownership is about the form of the report. (I
PHvM > won't copy the television broadcast, but that doesn't mean I
PHvM > won't use the information.)
Conventional usage. Agreed.
> JG>> The idea that one must be paid sums of cash in order to be
> JG>> considered a professional does not work well for me ...
> EVP> :-) :-) Do you really want to argue the definition of
> EVP> "professional" on that basis? :-) You've lost the moment you
> EVP> get out the gate. :-) :-).
PHvM > No, he hasn't, there is hope for Jeff yet: (-:
PHvM > ... Professional in the English languages seems to have two
PHvM > meanings:
PHvM > 1 Someone performing an action and being paid at least a normal
PHvM > fee for it.
PHvM > 2 Someone performing an action with high quality, and taking it
PHvM > seriously.
PHvM > (Dutch has different words for this.)
PHvM > Jeff wants definition 2.
That second definition does not appear in any reference avail-
able to me. I'm aware of colloquial usage in that direction but then
I'm also aware of colloquial quantification of "unique" which is
equally wrong.
Professional as defined by the American College Dictionary
available to me at my Vancouver base (as opposed to Calgary where I
have Funk & Wagnall, Webster and Horizon :-) lists eight definitions,
ALL associated with practice for livelyhood. Original usage pertained
to the three "professions": theology, law and medicine. Nowhere is it
defined as a degree in proficiency, which I'm afraid is what has
brought on incorrect colloquial usage.
Normally I don't get involved in arguments on semantics but in
this instance, professional is the only criteria that differentiates
between the individual who practises a craft for gain as opposed to
one who does the same thing for the love of it, which in turn IS the
definition of amateur. I have noted from the start that I have seen
better craft from many socalled amateurs than jaded pros. It does not
change word definitions, however.
PHvM > (What's this Fourth Estate? Is that Religion, Nobility, Trade,
PHvM > ... Jounalists, Labour?)
The Fourth Estate is The Press. The other three as you correctly
assume refer to other segments of civilization. Have forgotten the
precise definitions and have no references to same at this address.
> EVP>>> The press was never lily-white. There were always vindic-
> EVP>>> tive abusers of power ... but there was also greatness,
> EVP>>> courage and high principles at many ...
PHvM > ... That's what I was arguing, and that this is still true,
PHvM > but that we won't be able to see until it's in the past.
I'm not sure about that one :-). I prefer to recognize those
traits as they're practised around me in the present :-).
PHvM > Did you never ask anyone "Can I quote you on that?"? (-:
I have :-) but primarily to give someone a chance to rephrase an
inane or even stupid statement. The converse is also true. I've stop-
ped many from speaking "off-the-cuff" (non-quotable data) by saying:
"Don't tell me anything you don't want to see in print!" I always
liked to operate sans strings of any kind. That's why I habitually
argue when anybody tries to impose unwarranted restrictions.
PHvM > ... I do believe that the press should not be allowed to enter
PHvM > or damage someones privacy without permission...
This comes under good taste; good judgment, and class. Not
always associated with modern media :-).
PHvM > ... Difficult to write down, but I expect you understand what
PHvM > I mean.
Yes, and I enjoyed your input, Peter. --Erik
| AmiQWK 2.9 - FREEWARE |
... Wisdom consists of knowing when to avoid perfection.
--- DlgQWK v0.71a/PDQMail v2.60
* Origin: Commodore Computer Club Vancouver B.C. (604-231-0363) (1:153/911)