Slimelite BBS

OS4.0 Listing!

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-10 04:29 · #70472 in CLUB_AMIGA

Ross Nicoll wrote to Asha Develder in AMIGA about OS4.0 Listing!:


[Crunchers]

 RN>>> Most crunchers are perfectly safe.

Most crunchers are mostly safe. (Archivers more so than compressors).

 AD>> ... Harddrive prices are low enough these days to make that sort of thing less necessary than it used to be.

That's not true, of course. The larger the harddrives, the large the files people get used to handle. But somehow these files have to be transported, and this sometimes means floppies! The need changes, but it's still there.


 AD>> And there are programs (AutoPilot, for the Amiga and CIS, for example) that will NOT work correctly crunched.

That's true, but mostly for auto-decrunchers. (I don't know AutoPilot, so /I/ can't comment on the specifics. Maybe /you/ can.)


 RN> Oh yes, I'm not saying that they should be included in the OS ... I'm just trying to demonstrate that they are safe.

Go ahead, demonstrate. Most of them are not safe in all cases.


 RN> At a guess, AutoPilot didn't work because it tried to check the copy that was on disk.

Ah, same guess as mine: Auto-decrunching.


[Text gurus]

 RN>>> The question is, what help would a decent description be?

It makes the user feel like a human instead of the machine. People may joke about "general error" versus a whole lot of cryptic codes, but the "general error" is more user-friendly (if less useful) than the codes are.


 AD>> It might help the user when giving a bug report to a programmer.

I admit that I might remember a text easier than the codes, but the programmer might want the codes anyway (especially if these are more specific).

 AD>> But, I have read (recently) that by the time the GURU comes up there probably isn't enough system resourses to display that type of information.

No, that's not true. It might be so in some situations, (the red alerts are used as requesters when there isn't enough memory available to create a requester) but even then, that situation could be remedied by claiming such resources at startup.


 AD>> Maybe an alternative would be to list the more common GURU numbers (and their meanings) in an appendix in the docs.

Yes.


 RN> However, Guru numbers and their meanings are in the includes ...

That's not the point. If you buy a VCR you don't expect your manual to explain the complete theory of electro-magnetics. You do not even _want_ that. All you want is that it says whether you should shield it from something and how it should be grounded.

Even if we get every piece of documentation available for the Amiga on CD, we would still want some things "within easy reach", usually the things that should be done by the machine instead of us.
Unless the Amiga will come with a very sofisticated information manager, that allows you to find anything and will move much wanted information up, this means it will need a set of easy references.


 RN> To give you an example of how little information Gurus give, ...

We know that Gurus don't give very much information. Are you saying that the inadequacy of the error-report systems warrants its bad UI?


Team-amigo                                    Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg

...

--- April V1.05 
 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)