Slimelite BBS

Common Sense Wanted!

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-09 10:30 · #70467 in CLUB_AMIGA

In reply to Re: Common Sense Wanted! by Asha Develder

Asha Develder wrote to me in AMIGA about Common Sense Wanted!:

Asha,

  AD>>>>> I've paid full price for software that didn't deliver on its promises.
 PHM>> If it doesn't do what it's adverdised/described as doing; brin git back!

(I added these older quotes again.)

  AD>>> That's fine if you bought it from a retail outlet.  If the disks are not corrupted, most mail order houses won't take it back.
 PHM>> Force them (if it was their advertising), or go to the company itself (if it was theirs). (That's a bother, so you have to make your mind up about what you want: Ease, justice or money.)

  AD> It depends on what you mean by "it's their advertising".

See the older quotes: The program doesn't deliver on its promises. Most programs don't have an intro that falsly states what it doesm so "its" promises are usaully promisdes in advertising.
If it doesn't do what it is advertized to do, then who should take it back depends on who did advertize incorrect.

If the retailers advertizing states that the program does something it does not, or does worse then could be expected, then the retailer has to take it back. That's the law over here, and at least in some of the USA.
If the company did the advertizing, then they are obliged to take their product back from customers. It's easier if the retailer asks them to take the stuff back, but the retailer may have to deal with them again, and may not be willing to ask them.

 
  AD> They advertise their service,

If they only advertize their service, they have no direct obligation in this.


  AD> In each advertisement there is a small bit in tiny print that explains their return policy.  Most will not allow returns on items that are not defective.

Hm, that could be considered a loophole.
This could be explained as them being able to determine whether the products they sell are defective. As badly functioning programs can be considered defective this would could be used to force them to take it back.

(That's not my style of reasoning. I learned about it in the thread about sysops disclaiming responsibility regarding the messages on their BBS.)


  AD> Most companies that produce the programs will not return money for a program that was bought mail order because they'll loose money on it

Of course, returning a product loses everybody something. That doesn't free the company from it's responsibility though:
If the product doesn't work as advertized or as could be expected, the manufacturer has to take it back.


  AD> And I'm certainly not going to throw a major fit over something that cost me under $50 (most games)!

I wasn't talking about throwing a fit. (-: And I said before: getting you're money back from a manufacturer isn't easy. You have to be sure that that is what you want.


  AD> If you look at paint programs as an example you might see part of the problem.

Oh, I know parts of the problem. Above is one part, promised functionality, below is another, superficial differences.

  AD> There are about a half dozen paint programs out there currently. Each one is slightly different from the other, both in the tools they supply and the methods of using those tools.

  AD> Each artist works in a slightly different way than another artist. ...

Agreed. (-:

  AD> That doesn't mean the program is defective, only that it doesn't fit well with Artist B.
  AD> My solution has been, in those cases, to simply sell the software at a slight loss and move on. :)

The remedy to this is, of course, to find out if any of the manufacturers do give a no-satisfaction guarantee. If so, try out their products products first.
This leads to the conclusion that someone willing to take back product will actually sell more of it. (-: (Unfortunately this conclusion is based on the honesty of mankind, which is seldom accepted as an axiom. )-:)


Team-amigo                                    Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg

... How to get your pig down if it's stuck on the roof: 1 ...

--- April V1.05 
 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)