Slimelite BBS

Analogies

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-09 07:25 · #70416 in CLUB_AMIGA

Asha Develder wrote to Gary Peake in AMIGA about Analogies:

Asha,

 AD> I invented a new analogy today while trying to explain the difference between LHA and DMS; the DISH analogy.
 AD> The person I was posting to (Peter) wanted to know how they were different and why some files might not work if converted from DMS to LHA.  I explained that it was like packing dishes.
 AD> With DMS each dish was packed into the box in a precise place with a precise amount of space around it.
 AD> I added that if that file was unpacked and repacked with LHA those same "dishes" would be packed so that they took up the least amount of space in that box, without regard for any space around any spcial dish or glass.
 AD> I also said that in a LOT of cases it didn't matter, but that in some cases those spaces and arrangement were important for the file to work.
 AD> Holds up fairly well eh? :)


No, I don't agree with that. This way, I think, you told him a lie.



Let's take the traveling exhibition analogy:

Some exhibitions are merely a collection of artifacts. These are transported as Large Heaps of Art: Everything is packed into crates while trying to use as few crates as possible.

In every city the exhibition is unpacked, it is set up differently.


Other exhibitions are build together as series of tableaux. The exact place of the each item, and the tableau it is in, is important, as are the props in the tableaux.
These are transported as Deeply Meaningful Sets: The exhibition is packed in crates, (probably one tableau after the other,) and so are the props, as is a decription of the exact place of each item.

In every city the exhibition is unpacked each tableau is set up exactly the same, because of the decription.


Of course, it doesn't matter if you pack a simple collection as Deeply Meaningful Sets. That just means that it will look the same wherever it goes, even if that is unnecessary.
(It will give a problem unpacking if you do not have the required room handy. Unpackers are not all that bright and might walk against walls, or lose their way!)

If you pack tableaux as Large Heaps of Art however you will find that the next city has no idea how to set up the exhibition.
(What is left is a collection of artifacts. Packers are not all that bright, they probably not even added the props!)


Like it?



Team-amigo                                    Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg

By the way: How's the formatting on this one? (Still trying. (-:)

... Yes, but what about Packaging and Postage?

--- April V1.05 
 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)