Slimelite BBS

Press & Compuserve

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-09 05:12 · #70409 in CLUB_AMIGA

Erik V. Petersen wrote to Jeff Grimmett in AMIGA about Press & Compuserve:

  JG>> [It's hard to change to something new when you're comfortable.
  JG>>  See Papers to Radio to TV news. Onliners will get accepted.]

 EVP> [Radio and TV have the same structure, and profesionals, as papers.]

(Any new news medium is partly handled by amateurs, because there are not yet new professionals and (some of) the professionals in the old media don't recognize or accept it yet.)

 EVP>      In an electronic online conference you may want to equate the
 EVP> moderator with the editor but that's even a bit of a reach because
 EVP> there's little interpretation and no re-packaging (editing) done by
 EVP> the moderator. That's it. Contributors to a conference may or may not
 EVP> be competent communicators to gather or elicit information for their
 EVP> visualized audience.

No, you're wrong in this analogy: The online conference is not the reporting of news at all. It's generating the news.

The online conference is like the interview, the press conference, the remote conference and finaly the telephone conference.
All of them are about talking directly to the person whose opinions are considered news, but as more technology is involved it's possible to keep a larger distance between the target and the journalist.
(These distances seems to give the impression that the contact is also less sincere, hence the habbit of people to fall back to interview or press conference if they want to show that they are sincere.)

In each of these styles it is possible to let the reporter ask the questions, or to let others ask the questions and just report on what is being said.
Papers, Radio and TV have had these, shall we call them "audience conferences"? Most online conferences, as far as I know, come in that category.


Professional Cyberpress will again get the same structure as the other "press", as it has to deal with the same problems.
The difference is that, beginning with the first papers we have more and more begun to archive events as completely as possible, and cyberspace events might be archived completely.
Thus, like the LP and the video are alternatives to the radio and TV report of the concert, the archive will be an alternatvie there is an alternative (or complement) to the news-channel. (Apart from the rights.)



 EVP>      Transcription is after-processing or re-write depending on the capacity of the transcriber.

Well, it could depend a lot on his views too: Is one allowed to leave out comments of a parttaker? But is one allowed to show the breaches of netiquette that are made?

 EVP> In the Haynie transcript, Guidry walked a careful line cleaning up the worst noise and left most of the recorded transcript intact.

John must see that has the best way. That doesn't say much about his capbilities.

 EVP> (Nice Job, Jon! Thanks!).

If Jon reads this: Yes! And I'm glad you did it that way.


 EVP> Whereas a professional editor would have edited much more brutally,

I agree on the amount of changing, but not about the person doing it. I know there is a blurred line here, and I'm not trying to teach you your own job (-:, but here's as I see it:

The log of the conference is like the tape some journalists keep running a whole conference.

The journalist decides which parts are reported and how they are reported in the raw news item. That's what Jon does here.

The editor, if there is one, then molds it to fit in the style of the particular news-channel and the available space in it. There is no editor here as there is no specific news-channel here.



 EVP>>> Now, when Compuserve offers a service involving paid professional production, I shall never argue ownership.

No, but that ownership is about the form of the report. (I won't copy the television broadcast, but that doesn't mean I won't use the information.)


 EVP>>> If it is all volunteer work I believe that ownership becomes specious and highly questionable.

The ownership claimed is for the individual posters, and I agree that it's questionable, as I think the Berne agreement (What's the name?) was about pieces of art and science publications. (I read up on this, somewhat, after a previous thread. (-:)



  JG>> The idea that one must be paid sums of cash in order to be considered a professional does not work well for me ...

 EVP>      :-) :-) Do you really want to argue the definition of "professional" on that basis? :-) You've lost the moment you get out the gate. :-) :-).

No, he hasn't, there is hope for Jeff yet: (-:


 EVP If you're good enough at what you're doing, that somebody will pay you money for it, you're a professional.

That should be "if someone would be willing to pay" as far as I'm concerned.
Professional in the English languages seems to have two meanings:
1 Someone performing an action and being paid at least a normal fee for it.
2 Someone performing an action with high quality, and taking it seriously.

(Dutch has different words for this.)

Jeff wants definition 2.
You might be saying that you have to be 2 to be 1, but you'll probably agree that that's not necessarily so, unfortunately.


 EVP> That does not mean that some professional's standards may not be lower than a dedicated amateur -- one who does the job for the love of it even as he/she doesn't get paid for it.

I think I would define dedicated amateur as:
3 Someone performing an action, taking it seriously and not expecting being paid at least the normal fee for it.

Someone can't be 1 and 3 (unless one is extremely lacking in foresight (-:), but he can be 2 and 3, and you're agreeing that some 1's are not 2.


[Are (2 and 3)'s are not to be sneered at. Asha in particular.]

Ah, so that was this profesional subthread was about! I was totally lost at sea about it. (-:

Oh, and agreed on both.


 EVP> ... I suggested above that ownership of others volunteer work becomes questionable. If you pay the producer for the work, now you can claim ownership in most any court.

No, I disagree. The volunteers, when producing a work of art or of science, have the same rights as the profesionals (1's).

However, the only thing Asha or Compuserve can have a claim on is the interaction during the conference, as that's what they produced. They can't claim the actual words, apart from Asha for her part, and nobody can claim the ideas, of course.


 EVP>>> Now, either you, or it could have been somebody else, sneered at the Fourth Estate, the modern press, and when I see opinionated kids without wisdom spout their pat, programmed views in the guise of news reporting, I get somewhat ill myself.

Could that have been Jeremy and me talking? (What's this Fourth Estate? Is that Religion, Nobility, Trade, ...  Jounalists, Labour?)


 EVP>>>  The press was never lily-white. There were always vindictive abusers of power ... but there was also  greatness, courage and high principles at many ...

If it was us: That's what I was arguing, and that this is still true, but that we won't be able to see until it's in the past.


 EVP>> I simply questioned their's or anybody's right to forbid any publication and/or discussion of anything newsworthy happening on their lines.

Then you needn't have bothered. Compuserve don't forbid the publication of a conference, they claim that on-line writing is copyright of the posters.

That's just the same with all the other press. Did you never ask anyone "Can I quote you on that?"? (-:

But I don't think someones words are copyright. On the other hand, I do believe that the press should not be allowed to enter or damage someones privacy without permission.
That means that you can't quote, or film someone in private or describe this private situation, but you can use public information, even if it is acquired in a private place.

Difficult to write down, but I expect you understand what I mean.

Anyway: That means that it is legal to tell the whole world the information that Hayne and others gave at that conference except the parts about themselves and their family.
For those private bits, you would need their permission, and that's the permision they all were asked for.


Thanks for writing this, as it made me form my opinion about all this much better.

You don't


Team-amigo                                    Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg

... Most disagreements are just differences in definitions.

--- April V1.05 
 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)