From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-06 06:05 · #69948 in CLUB_AMIGA
Patrick Bartek wrote to me in AMIGA about Copying is plagiarism.: PB> In article 'Copying is plagiarism.', Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg wrote: PHM>> Asha, PL>>>>> Ever hear of "plagiarism"? If you copy software without permission, that's de facto plagiarism, PB> Wrong! Plagiarism is stealing someone else's intellectual property and claiming it to be your own. First of all: Five messages ago: PL who is Paula Lieberman, wrote that line. Four messages ago: I replied that I never had seen that approach before, and asked whether there were precedents to support it. Three messages ago: Asha, in an explanation, claimed that you don't buy software but use it. Two messages ago: I stated that this was not the same thing, as you don't claim to have developed it if you write the program. Also, I voiced my doubt on the validaty of the "license to use" idea. One message ago: You replied to that line to me, who hadn't written it, with an argument, akin to the one I made in that same message that you quoted from. (See, that's how a good quote system works.) Next: Plagiarism is copying, not stealing, as far as I am concerned. If someone walks into the "Louvre" and walks out holding the Mona Lisa, then sets up an auction to sell the beautiful painting (s)he made yesterday (Sorry, you can't touch it, the paint is still wet.) that's not plagiarism. That's theft, imposture, and disposing of stolen goods. On the other hand: If a painter studies the Mona Lisa carefully, until (s)he knows every technique Da Vinci used when painting it, and is skillful enough to make a copy, then goes out and claims to have thought of those techniques her/him-self; that's plagiarism. But finally: Maybe, in this new medium, if we make a copy of a program we imply that we are the authors of an original. In this context I can tell you that I know of a huge corporation where every drawing that left the research-departments had to be signed by the head of the department. Blue-prints, being mechanical copies could carry the copy of the signature, but two print-outs of the same CAD-design had to be signed seperately, and were therefore considered seperate originals. PB> What you're talking about is copyright violation. Plagiarism /is/ a copyright violation. PB> When you "buy" software, you're not really "buying" it. PB> You are purchasing a license to use it under the conditions set by the developer or his agent, which is usually the right to make ONE backup copy, to install it on ONE computer, and be able to USE it forever without paying any additional fees. Yes, that's what Asha said, and I said I doubted that this still held. I think that this was tested in court and ruled illegal, but I'm not sure. The problem is that shops don't usually sell licenses to use copies of something. They usually sell the articles themselves. So maybe this argument, that it's just a license to use, is nonsense. PB> The above situation is very much like in my business. I've been a commercial photographer for twenty years and the fees that business's pay me for photography have a similar "licensing" arrangement. You don't tell what arrangement. How does it work, and what are those similarities? And, fo course, will this hold for pictures drawn with an Amiga as well? (-: Team-amigo Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg ... Parcs are the pigeons way to tame humans. --- April V1.05 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)