Slimelite BBS

Amiga V/S PC

Back to CLUB_AMIGA

From Peter Hans van den Muij · 1996-04-05 23:32 · #69940 in CLUB_AMIGA

The Anti-Christ wrote to Derek Woodlands in AMIGA about Ami V/S PC:

Warning: This part of the message is written in Anti-Amiga flamer style.
Move to the second half of the message for the actual information.


  DW> In a message of 08 Mar 96 The Anti-Christ wrote

Ha, ha, ha, ha. Can't be of much use with such a name.

 TAC>>> probs, is a pretty good description of an amiga!! hey, when are they

Hey, don't know wath you're talking about can't write English or something!!


 TAC>>> gunna release doom on the amiga? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA NEVER!!!!

What would we want Dumb for? We don't use that kind of PC-shitware.
Our 3D shoot-um-up's are much better, and you don't have to buy a P133, to have it run above snailspeed.
Hey I wish that they did a module where there were banks of PC's all around, then we could blast them all away, ha, ha, ha, ha.


 DW>> I hate to have to inform you, but Doom has been available for the Amiga for quite some time.  The Amiga version is called Gloom for copyright reasons.

 TAC> Ohhhh, so its not an official release then!

Offalcial? We don't need no offalcial PC-stuf, we need good stuff, and that can only be done on an Amiga nodoubtabout it.

 TAC> gee it would be realy good!

No, not really good. Great! And best of all, no PC involved!!!

 TAC> what does it need to run well?

Hey, all Amiga programs run well. You don't have to buy another idiot machine every six months because you can't play Dumb, or X-failure, or EveryOneWillFail if you don't

 TAC> an amiga 4000 with 4gb "fast ram"

Na, only PC's need that much memroy, because otherwise they would start swapping to harddrive, and they have these really slow IDE harddrives, that no-one would want to use if they could help it.


 TAC> (HAHAHAHA what a joke "fast ram" yay its probably 100ns instead of 150ns)

Hey, what about PC DMA. Direct Memory Access. Direct Memory COnflict is a better name. You guys can't even plug in a grafix card without crashing the computer.

 TAC>  DW> Oh, then there is Alien Breed 3D.
 TAC> wow!
 TAC> gee, how many colours can the amiga do at a decent speed???

What about a PC. If you startup those, you get this stupid C:> prompt on a black screen, or you get Windozzzze if you are willing to wait half an hour while it is loading. All Amigi give you colors right out of the box fast.
We want16 milion colors? We got it! you, you got to buy a card plug it in crash the computer buy another card. By the time the machine works it's no good anymore you need a new one every five months


 TAC> i have a crappy 486 100

You can say that again.

  TAC> and can do 16.7mil colours at a half decent speed!

At HALF decent speed. Says it all, ha  ha ha ha!!!

 TAC> cam amigas do 16bit sterio sound at 44khz?? with unlimeted chanels???

Can PC's do sound that's worth listening to. No, they do beep, and when you add a lot of hardware they give the same crappy sound in 16 bits.

 TAC> can you use IDE hdds? or do you have to use expencive scsi ones?

IDE? Yeach!! Yes we could but who wants a harddrive that is so slow!! SCSI harddrives don't cost more if you take the trouble to look for them, and then you don't have to wait until your CD is ready before you can use your harddisk.
And we don't need 15 parallel ports for everything that should be on SCSI


 TAC> i have a 1gig quantum fireball EIDE hdd that absolutly screams. 8mb/sec burst transfer, 3.5mb/sec sustained transfer.

And you need it with your PC, you need something faster, but you can't get it.
PC's always need it bigger and faster. We can use the same stuff for years, and we can simply add a harddrive if we want. No use for harddisk so big that you don't know what you're doing withit.

 TAC> Ooooo and the good thing you can buy them for around $350 aus. how much would a 1gig scsi cost?

Can't you stop asking the same questions? If an IDE costs $350, then a SCSI can be had for $350. But man, it *does* sound expensive to me. I could by that for f 300,- if I wanted, but I don't want that I don't want no stinking IDE drives in my Amiga.

 TAC> what is the newest os for amiga?

The newest OS is 3.1. Our OS is good enough were not racing for DOS10.x. That's just for clones, where they can't write a decent OS, so a new one comes out everyyear

 TAC> lets just face it, with the ibm clone market you can buy a far superior pc at a fraction of the cost of an amiga.

Hey, face it. Even if that were true, who would want it. The only guys buying clones are doing so because the company did so 15 years ago, and they're trapped ever since.
Or guuys who want to play Dumb and don't bother to look at superior machines. But you can't buy a superior PC at a fraction of a cost there areNO SUPERIOR MACHINES. THE AMiga RULES>

 TAC>  * Origin: Sight & Sound multimedia BBS (3:713/818)

Must be blind and deaf, if it's using an clone!








OK. It's safe now. (-:
I didn't mean anything of the above, of course. It's just a style exercise.
I've seen to many posts in that style, and my point is that it does not get any message across, it just irritates people.


Next is my style: This is the same post, but this time I'll _answer_ it.





The Anti-Christ wrote to Derek Woodlands in AMIGA about Ami V/S PC:

Hello. Would you mind telling us your real name? I would rather like to know your name because it's nicer to write to a real person. (There's also an echo-rule about it, I think.)


 TAC>>> hey, when are they gunna release doom on the amiga? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA NEVER!!!!

I think you're right. When Doom became a success on the PC's the software house had no plans for an Amiga release. But on the Amiga such gaps are filled by the PD programmers, so now there are several good Doom look-alikes on the Amiga.
Some would say these are better then the original, some say their just/nearly as good, but the point is that there no longer is a market for an Amiga port of Doom.


 TAC> an amiga 4000 with 4gb "fast ram"(HAHAHAHA what a joke "fast ram" yay its probably 100ns instead of 150ns)

This "fast ram" is ram where the central processor will never have to wait for co-processors. In the Amiga the workload is shared by several chips.
That means that the central processor doesn't have to do eg. all the graphics manipulations, that's done by other chips, which use DMA to change the memory as necessary.
Part of the memory is for the central processor only, so it won't have to wait when other chips do DMA. That's fastmem.
There are a lot of graphics in Doom, so it might be that it doesn't need much fastmem, but needs chipmem instead. That's the part of memory that all chips have access to.


 TAC> gee, how many colours can the amiga do at a decent speed???

This depends on what you call decent speed, of course. I still have an A1000, because I mostly use the graphics for the Workbench, which is the Grafical user interface, akin to Windows or OS/2.
I never felt the need to upgrade that as the extra chips let the processor go on with the real work while the graphics are updated by seperate chips, which all in all is speed enough for me.
But at the top of the line, there are 24-bit boards similar to the PC ones, and the coproccesors make up for the slightly slower processor. So in all, an Amiga would probably do the same amount of colours at a decent speed as a comparable PC.


 TAC> i have a crappy 486 100 and can do 16.7mil colours at a half decent speed!

I don't like it when people call things crappy. Think back at the PC's, XT's and AT's. (And those are still in use!) Your 486 is much better, and faster.
It's a good machine, even if it isn't state of the art anymore. (Mind you, it's not my taste, but we can't argue about taste, can we?)


 TAC> cam amigas do 16bit sterio sound at 44khz?? with unlimeted chanels???

They don't do so out of the box, just like PC's. PC's only have the internal speaker, out of the box, Amigi only do 8 bit 4 channel stereo, out of the box.
I don't know about the frequency you mentioned. (The sound is alright with me, so I never gave it much attention.)
But just like with the PC there are soundcards for the Amiga. I do not think they are as popular as the PC-cards though.
The sound of the standard Amiga is usually good enough. For example, games don't really need the extra features of sound-cards, which means less hassle setting them up.


 TAC> can you use IDE hdds?

Yes, we can. The cheaper, lower-end, models do, but a lot of people prefer SCSI.


 TAC> or do you have to use expencive scsi ones?

SCSI is not that expensive. As a matter of fact, part of the business stopped quoting different prices for IDE and SCSI.

But anyway, some people prefer SCSI, simply because, compared to standard IDE, it can handle more devices at the same time. It can also handle a far wider range of devices, like scanners for example.


 TAC> i have a 1gig quantum fireball EIDE hdd that absolutly screams. 8mb/sec burst transfer, 3.5mb/sec sustained transfer.

I have a .5G maxtor SCSI drive. I don't know the precise specs, but it's fast enough (and more than big enough) for me.


 TAC> Ooooo and the good thing you can buy them for around $350 aus. how much would a 1gig scsi cost?

It cost me fl 250,- (160 USD?), but they would be cheaper now. Considering that the price of a harddrive does not double with it's size I'd say that the 1G equivalent of my Harddrive would not cost as much as 250 USD; but I could be wrong.
But anyway, if you feel you paid a good price for at, I'm glad you did. (-: Sometimes it seems that, though computers can do more and more, the price also goes up each time. )-:


 TAC> what is the newest os for amiga?

The newest OS is 3.1. But I guess that wouldn't mean much to you. If you would like to know what the OS was like, I'm sure there are poeple here in the echo, who use it, who can give you a good description of what it does.
Probably, if you find someone who doesn't live to far away, they'll let you try it out for yourself. (Come to think of it, I doubt that many people would invite the AntiChrist into their homes. (-:)


 TAC> lets just face it, with the ibm clone market you can buy a far superior pc at a fraction of the cost of an amiga.

Well, fraction is literally true, but gives the wrong impression. The PC hardware is cheaper because of the economy of scale, yes, but it's not like a top Amiga costs 4000 USD and the equivalent PC costs 400 USD.

Also, if you are trying out the Amiga somewhere, you should take note of the OS. Many owners of Amigi bought the Amiga because they were willing to pay a little more for what they consider a better OS.

And as I wrote before, the PD scene for the Amiga is very sofisticated. The quantity of programs may be less then on the PC, but the standard is very high.
As PD usually costs less than the enormous releases from software houses, you might break even after all, if you did need software with your machine (more so if you kept your Amiga longer).


I hope this is of any help to you,
Team-amigo                                    Peter Hans van den Muijzenberg

... It's not what it costs, but what it does, that matters.

--- April V1.05 
 * Origin: The world is beautiful, from my viewpoint. (2:282/357.36)