From Jeff Grimmett · 1996-04-05 16:36 · #69927 in CLUB_AMIGA
In a message dated 03 Apr 96 21:00:00, Erik V. Petersen wrote:
JGr > Naturally... when one is used to "this is how things get done"
JGr > inside an industry, it isn't easy to accept that there are
JGr > other ways to produce something similar, maybe better, maybe
JGr > worse, using a different media.
JGr > The traditional newshounds had the same reactions to radio
JGr > ("that isn't news!!") and TV was similarly pummeled by the then-
JGr > entrenched radio jockeys. Now the online information road is the
JGr > latest whipping boy of the media insiders, under attack from all
JGr > fronts, but when you look at the big picture it isn't any great
JGr > suprise. I imagine that 10-20 year from now, politicos will
JGr > schmooze for the onliners the same way they suck up to TV came-
JGr > ras like thier mothers' teats nowadays.
EVP> Some apple and orange mixing here. We were talking news not just
EVP> media. In the news end, the electronic media evolved with the struc-
EVP> ture of the print media. Editors, newswriters, reporters and photo-
EVP> graphers (for TV). Still professional input but generally with less
EVP> depth treatment in the electronic media.
Maybe you CHOOSE to view it as apples and oranges, but I do not. At the very core of your objection to CIS is that they are not spreading thier information wide and far, free as the wind, simply because they're an electronic medium and you're used to freebies from the electronic medium. If a newspaper charges you $.25 to read an interview with Lee Iococca, you accept it complacently. If Time magazine charges you $2.00 to read an interview with Mick Jagger, you accept it, plain and simple. Yet, if CIS provides the same thing, an interview with Dave Haynie, you balk at paying them the same fee you would to any of the other non-electronic rags in the world.
If I photocopied the previously mentioned interviews and spread them around the world, I would be guilty in your eyes. If I did the same with the Haynie interview, without permission, I get the impression you'd cheer for me.
In all three cases I did the same thing: broke the term of the copyright. How can you respect the rights of the previous two and not the third?
EVP> In an electronic online conference you may want to equate the
EVP> moderator with the editor but that's even a bit of a reach because
EVP> there's little interpretation and no re-packaging (editing) done by
EVP> the moderator. That's it. Contributors to a conference may or may
EVP> not be competent communicators to gather or elicit information for their
EVP> visualized audience.
Conference, email forum, it doesn't matter. Either you respect the laws of copyright, or you don't.
And you're doing it again: apparently, only if one has gone through years of trial and tribulation in the trenches are thier words worthy of protection. Well, Erik, that positively reeks and smacks of disrespect to many people who have important, insightful things to say but haven't gone the same route you have.
I doubt you meant it that way, but I can't read your mind...
EVP> Transcription is after-processing or re-write depending on the
EVP> capacity of the transcriber. In the Haynie transcript, Guidry walked
EVP> a careful line cleaning up the worst noise and left most of the re-
EVP> corded transcript intact. (Nice Job, Jon! Thanks!). Whereas a profes-
EVP> sional editor would have edited much more brutally, boiling the ma-
EVP> terial down from 10% to 50% depending on focus of visualized audien-
EVP> ce. He would have wiped out most noise other than color, using para-
EVP> phrasing paragraphs as glue.
So... let me see if I got this straight: one must be brutal to be protected under copyright law? One must be a "professional?"
JGr > How does a free newsletter differ from a quarter-a-copy newspa-
JGr > per, other than the amount of money in the owners' pockets?
EVP> Newsletters are almost always vertical, special-interest publi-
EVP> cations where a newspaper is a horizontal, wide-audience consumer
EVP> product. Either can be produced professionally or amateurishly. Most
EVP> lasting publications are produced professionally.
You didn't answer my question in the context of this discussion. If I wanted a definition of the word "newsletter" I could have looked it up. Let me be more specific, then: How do copyright laws apply to "professional" publications and not "special-interest" publications? Note that I am likely to make you eat the words "Special Interest" if you're not very, very careful. :-)
JGr > The idea that one must be paid sums of cash in order to be con-
JGr > sidered a professional does not work well for me, other than in
JGr > the letter of the law for certain situations.
EVP> :-) :-) Do you really want to argue the definition of "profes-
EVP> sional" on that basis? :-) You've lost the moment you get out the
EVP> gate. :-) :-). If you're good enough at what you're doing, that some-
EVP> body will pay you money for it, you're a professional. That does not
EVP> mean that some professional's standards may not be lower than a dedi-
EVP> cated amateur -- one who does the job for the love of it even as he/
EVP> she doesn't get paid for it.
I don't intend to base my evaluation of what's "Professional" on that, at all, which is why I said what I said. What I'm wondering to myself is what YOUR idea of "professional" is.
JGr > If one donates thier services, yet does thier job well, are they
JGr > to be sneered at by those earning a living at the same thing?
JGr > Is that the only benchmark for one's performance, Erik?
EVP> For one who has always championed the talented amateur over the
EVP> jaded pro, that shot comes as something of a surprise. Now where did
EVP> you get that idea?
If I have to pull your chain to get your attention, I'll do it.
EVP> I've sneered at no one, and most certainly not at
EVP> our mutual friend, Asha, who moderated the Haynie conference. I bark-
EVP> ed to her, never sneered at her :-).
I'm glad you're becoming aware of who's efforts you're questioning, as that's the intention of several of my comments.
EVP> You will note, however, that I
EVP> suggested above that ownership of others volunteer work becomes que-
EVP> stionable. If you pay the producer for the work, now you can claim
EVP> ownership in most any court.
That is precisely what CIS subsribers do. They pay the electronic information service for what that service provides to them. In this case, it was the privelege of talking directly to none other than Dave Haynie. They also pay for the privelege of talking directly to J. Micheal Strazynski (sp), Peter David, and a number of other luminaries outside of the Amiga sphere of influence.
By tacking on that copyright disclaimer, they protect thier clients. AND, of course, attract more, which is why copyright laws exist in the first place -- commerce. Protection of what you've written in the past on paper, protection for NewsWeek, protection for Reuters, Knight-Ridder, and UPI. (all, incidentally, which offer electronic versions that are NOT free, but which you do not seem to object to).
EVP> Never argued that point.
JGr > The Enquirer and Merc News get thiers, can not CIS, Genie, and
JGr > even AOHell get thiers?
EVP> Apples and oranges with a few sour grapes thrown in. They obvi-
EVP> ously get out of it what they want, or they wouldn't remain in busi-
EVP> ness. I simply questioned their's or anybody's right to forbid any
EVP> publication and/or discussion of anything newsworthy happening on
EVP> their lines.
When it is not objectionable for me to photocopy and spread around YOUR work as "newsworthy" then I'll view that a bit more charitable. Until then, the protection has to apply to ALL.
-O Jeff Grimmett (jgrimm@bitnova.com) O-
-= Team Amiga =- -= Team DLG =- -= Team Hersheys =-
--- DLG Pro v1.1/PDQMail v2.61
* Origin: Techno-Mages Guild * 619 549-7742 * San Diego (1:202/720)