Slimelite BBS

ACR

Back to REGION25

From Denis McMahon · 1996-04-09 08:06 · #69015 in REGION25

In reply to ACR by Mike Jagdis

Hi Mike

 It appears that on Sat 06 Apr 
 Mike Jagdis said to Denis McMahon ....

DM>> DM>> then we must also allow the sociological arguments in favour
DM>> DM>> of ACR to carry the same weight.

DM>> MJ> I've no problem with that but nobody will offer one :-(.

DM>> Rubbish, all the arguments in favour of ACR on a Fido line have been on 
DM>> sociological rather than technical grounds. If you're suggesting that 
DM>> some of the pro-ACR arguments have some technical basis within P4 and 
DM>> FTS-0001, then you must accept that ACR must be permitted.

MJ> Sorry, I meant that I haven't seen any *arguments* in favour of ACR. I've 
MJ> seen plenty of statements that it is a Good Thing but *no one* has argued 
MJ> the point!

Several people have argued the point on both sides, however all the arguments on both sides have been sociological. The fact that you do not recognise pro-ACR arguments as having any substance does not mean that no-one has made a case for ACR.

The sole significant fact is that the combination of CLI with-hold on the calling line and ACR on the called line will cause a call to fail.

There is no justification to allow either and disallow the other. Both represent a subscriber controlled deviation from the default line conditions for a telephone line (which is to present CLI and to accept anonymous calls).

Until there is a clear identification in FTS standards and/or Policy as to which is permissible, both should be prohibited on Fido lines.

Rgds
Denis
dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se

--- MsgedSQ 3.35
 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)