From Denis McMahon · 1996-04-01 22:20 · #68936 in REGION25
In reply to ACR by Martyn Wilkins
Hi Martyn It appears that on Fri 29 Mar Martyn Wilkins said to Denis McMahon .... >> Should CLI withhold not be used ditto. MW> True, however that is not allways wise. Arguments have been stated for MW> this. I've yet to see any technical argument based on either FTS-0001 or P4 for the use of CLI with-hold, all I've seen to date are sociological arguments. As you say, they are hollow under scrutiny and don't hold water. >> For every argument that it is the node using ACR that is at fault, there is >> a counter argument that it is the node using CLI withhold that is at >> fault. MW> Indeed. And most seem to me to be hollow under scrutiny, and boring. Exactly, all arguments that both sides have put forwards to justify the allowance of one and the prohibition of the other are the same. Sociological, not technically based on either FTS-0001 or P4. The answer is simple, either accept that the sociological arguments are valid and allow both CLI withhold and ACR, or state that the sociological arguments are not valid and forbid both. As the former course of action might lead to the situation where FTS-0001 calls might not connect, the better course of action would be to prohibit both. The only sociological solution is for the users of both CLI withhold and ACR services to agree that if a call fails it is as much their own fault as the other persons. Rgds Denis denis.mcmahon@f20.n251.z2.fidonet.org / dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se --- MsgedSQB 3.30.02 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)