From Mike Jagdis · 1996-03-30 01:46 · #68897 in REGION25
BB> In summary, it is feasible but impractical to tackle
BB> deliberately anonymous telephone calls in a different way
BB> from BT ACR.
Where "anonymous" means "you didn't tell me the number you called from". What makes such a call inherently bad? As far as the vast majority are concerned *all* calls are anonymous by your definition. Until recently the minority didn't even exist. Your fundamental premise is unproven and seemingly garbage.
BB> That it is also technically inaccurate I will leave to Denis
BB> McMahon to prove to you.
I *know* the difference between ACR and CLID checking. But every time I ask how ACR helps "security" I get some crap about logging CLID or comparing it against a "list". Even you do it.
BB> As to the history of Fido and the purpose of ZMH, I do
BB> not need history lessons from you or anybody else, Mike. I
BB> have been here while most of it was happening.
That's what makes it so sad. Everything I know about you tells me that you *must* know you are talking crap. But you carry on doing it instead of giving a simple explanation of how you arrived at your conclusions. <sigh>
BB> Nevertheless John Richardson recently opened a breach in
BB> our interpretation of Policy 4 that may never be repaired.
My opinion of Policy is a matter of record. I couldn't give a toss about it. It's open to more interpretation then the Bible! :-)
BB> The words of Policy 4 do not support your arguments.
But since you insist let's take a look at the One True Document for a bit of light entertainment :-).
1.2.1 Individual Systems and System Operators
[...] The sysop must mesh
with the rest of the FidoNet system to send and receive mail, [...]
1.3.3 Zone Mail Hour
Zone Mail Hour (ZMH) is a defined time during which all nodes in
a zone are required to be able to accept netmail. [...]
2.1.8 Exclusivity of Zone Mail Hour
Zone Mail Hour is the heart of FidoNet, as this is when network
mail is passed between systems. Any system which wishes to be a
part of FidoNet must be able to receive mail during this time
using the protocol defined in the current FidoNet Technical
Standards Committee publication (FTS-0001 at this writing). It
is permissible to have greater capability (for example, to
support additional protocols or extended mail hours), but the
minimum requirement is FTS-0001 capability during this one hour
of the day.
This time is exclusively reserved for netmail. Many phone systems
charge on a per-call basis, regardless of whether a connect, no
connect, or busy signal is encountered. [...]
2.1.10 Observing Mail Events
Failure to observe the proper mail events is grounds for any node
to be dropped from FidoNet without notice (since notice is generally
given by netmail).
Far from not supporting the argument it appears that your Policy does require the ability to receive mail as documented in FTS-0001. Even this brief scan would appear to contradict your (unsubstantiated) claim. Have I, perhaps, got the *wrong* Policy here? :-)
Mike
---
* Origin: The Purple Tentacle +44 1734 266974 (2:252/305)