Slimelite BBS

Anon Call Rejection.

Back to REGION25

From Dave Langridge · 1996-03-29 13:28 · #68894 in REGION25

Richard James wrote in a message to Dave Langridge:

 RJ> I haven't seen any such decision from the RC.

Then I shall post it in here for you to see.

=============================================================================
* Forwarded by Keith Wassell (2:440/1)
* Area : REGION25 (Region25 sysops)
* From : Keith Wassell, 2:440/1 (Monday March 18 1996 06:31)
* To   : Bob Henson
* Subj : Anon Call Rejection.
=============================================================================
Hello Bob!

Thursday March 14 1996 09:01, Bob Henson wrote to Keith Wassell:


 -=>> Quoting Keith Wassell to Jim O'Neill <=-

 JO>> OK, make it a requirement for a Fido Node to _NOT_ have ACR
 JO>> during ZMH (and at ANY time if they are flagged CM).

 KW>> my thoughts entirely

 BH> Surely it already IS a requirement, Keith? If I were to password you
 BH> out of my system, you would quite rightly be peevish, and could make
 BH> a sustainable XAB complaint on those grounds. There would be no
 BH> difference if I were to reject your calls because you called from an
 BH> unlisted (unlisted in Fidonet, that is) number, in either case I
 BH> would be refusing a call from a legitimate node and in breach of
 BH> Policy.

 BH> Whilst admiring your non-interference policy of the last year or so,
 BH> this is one case where, should a complaint be made to you, I don't
 BH> see how you could not rule that there was a clear breach of Policy
 BH> and would have to act on it if the node continued to reject calls
 BH> repeatedly. I know you've been anxious to avoid controversy, and
 BH> hope you will continue to do the same if re-elected ..... but you
 BH> would surely have the backing of the huge majority if you were
 BH> forced to make a stand on this by some twerp with no more sense than
 BH> to listen to a reasonable request from yourself to comply with
 BH> Policy.

couldn't agree with you more Bob, but, sitting back and watching this dispute
has again for me been part of the process of gaining concencus on how it should
be. There are some extreme views, on all sides. Being reasonable is what its all
about. Having been around for so long, you and I know there is always some twerp
out to try and break someones system, and ACR helps guard against that.

***************

==============================================================================
On the flip, we have a policy that says 'thou shalt be callable in ZMH, and 24
hrs if marked CM'. That policy has not changed, and , If ACR interferes with
that in any way, then it must not be used.
==============================================================================

****************

All the rest of the background arguments are noise, but, rather than just 'jump'
i've spent time listening and forming an opinion on how to 'interpret' policy in
this area correctly. I believe what I have highlighted above to be the answer,
regardless of my personal feelings on ACR.

Regards,
        Keith

-!- GoldED/386/2.42.G0615+/#0020UK1
 ! Origin: P C FORUM * GUILDFORD UK * +44-1483-821183 & 821184 (2:440/1)
=============================================================================

There...the bit between the asterisks is what you need to read Richard...


        Dave L. 


--- GEcho 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: Home At Last! in the Pleiades Cluster (2:252/820)