Slimelite BBS

ACR

Back to REGION25

From Denis McMahon · 1996-03-30 15:49 · #68887 in REGION25

Hi Jim

 It appears that on Thu 28 Mar 
 Jim O'Neill said to Denis McMahon ....

JO> Why would connectivity be disrupted by using 141.

Sunshine, if ACR prevents connectivity, so does CLI withhold! That's the bottom line. Neither affects connectivity unless both are used, in the case that both are used then either both ends must be at fault, or neither end.

DM>> If node a calls node b, and node a and node b have incompatible phone 
DM>> lines, but either of them can take action that will make the phone lines 
DM>> compatible, neither node can be individually blamed for the 
DM>> incompatibility.

JO> BUT!, 

But nothing - I made no mention of ACR or CLI withhold in that paragraph, so *YOU* can stop introducing extraneous data to the equation!

DM>> Here is another example, effectively CLI in reverse. Assume the caller 
DM>> has the ability to require the actual number the call is connected to, 
DM>> and the called party refuses to release it. The call is blocked because 
DM>> of this. Who is at fault?

JO> Why 

"Why" has nothing to do with the equation - "Why" is a sociological factor and is nothing to do with being nodelisted or not.

JO> That is, all of us against ACR could be summed up as: "THERE IS NO NEED 
JO> FOR THE CALLED NUMBER (with ACR) TO HAVE THE NUMBER OF THE LINE CALLING 
JO> THEM".

By the way, anyone who quotes part of the following sentence out of context of the rest of it demonstrates a lack of grasp of the problem:
 
"THERE IS NO TECHNICAL NEED OR BASIS WITHIN EITHER FTS-0001 OR P4 FOR THE CALLING NUMBER TO WITHHOLD THEIR IDENTITY, NOR IS THERE ANY TECHNICAL NEED OR BASIS IN P4 OR FTS-0001 FOR THE CALLING NODE TO REQUIRE THE NUMBER OF THE CALLER."

It's my works number ....
It's my voice number ....
I have a right to privacy ....
I might get burgled ....

None of these have anything to do with FTS-0001 or ZMH, they are all sociological.

And finally, as above, the following is a single paragraph and should not be partially quoted:

Now, having established that (a) there is no technical basis in either FTS-0001 or P4 for CLI withhold, and that (b) there is no technical basis in either FTS-0001 or P4 for ACR, they should both be prohibited within FidoNet until such time as a means is found of allowing them to co-exist.
Rgds
Denis

denis.mcmahon@f20.n251.z2.fidonet.org / dmcmahon@edlgu4.ericsson.se

--- MsgedSQB 3.30.02
 * Origin: SET UAFALTERNATE 1 00:00-06:00 (2:251/20)