Slimelite BBS

DUNBLANE ATROCITY

Back to AMIGA_NF

From David Yates · 1996-04-11 19:28 · #68824 in AMIGA_NF

Quoting PAUL GARDNER to DAVID YATES on 04-05-96 16:58 on the subject of 
DUNBLANE ATROCITY

PG>You might, millions wouldn't. Let's put it another way; if people
PG>really didn't want what you consider to be "intrusive" coverage, they
PG>would boycott those newspapers and broadcasters. The classic case of
PG>a paper misjudging the public mood was the Sun's Hillsborough
PG>coverage - the resulting boycott hit them where it hurts most, in the
PG>pocket

In countries where there are public executions, public floggings and 
public amputations, these events draw large crowds. IMHO these 
punishments are not justified by their popularity. We also have to 
consider the position of the victim who is being brutalised for a crime 
he may not have committed. 

So it is with tabloid intrusiveness. The fact that people want to hear 
gossip, does not justify the gossip.

As for popular opinion, I think this is ambivalent. Most people dislike 
the worst excesses of the tabloids, even though they may be tabloid 
readers

PG> PG> down on motorways when there has been an accident on the other
PG> PG> side?

As a side issue, I was stuck in a tailback for over an hour the other 
day on the M6. The tailback was caused by an accident on the *other 
side* of the road. People on my side were holding up the traffic behind 
them while they gawped at the wreckage.

PG>Sounds reasonable enough in theory but it's not so simple in
PG>practice. Given the vagaries of our archaic legal system, I can tell
PG>you for starters that the mass of ordinary, decent folk won't get a
PG>look in.  

It depends whether or not they would have to go to court to get a ruling 
against the newspaper. If greater powers were given to a complaints 
commission, perhaps justice would be accessible to all.

PG>If this family happened to be the victims in the Ealing vicarage rape
PG>case, I wouldn't be surprised that you felt that way. That kind of 
PG>salacious reporting gave the industry a very bad name and led to
PG>major  changes in the coverage of rape cases.

It wasn't the Ealing rape case and nothing has changed since, AFAICS

PG>In the case of public figures, the situation is more complicated.
PG>When an MP stands on a platform of "family values" and parades his
PG>family to get himself elected, I would have no qualms about "outing"
PG>them. These people are in a position of power over the rest of us; we
PG>have a right to expect them to live by the rules that they make for
PG>us. However, no public interest is served by revealing that someone
PG>like Frank Bough visits prostitutes IMO.

I completely agree, there needs to be a public interest distinction.

david@yates.dungeon.com
04/11/96
---
* CMPQwk #1.4* UNREGISTERED EVALUATION COPY

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin: Ooh! BBS, London [MULTILINES]  0181-395-3108  (2:254/233.0)