Slimelite BBS

Re: Soundoff about Boots

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Paul Dickie · 1996-04-13 19:52 · #68804 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Re: Soundoff about Boots by Pat Winstanley

Greetings!

 -=> Quoting Philip Sands to David Yates <=-

 >DY> of others. Rest assured, Boots *will* be having a good look at your
 >DY> photos to make sure you aren't doing anything which *they* disapprove
 >DY> of. Rest assured also, that they will be contacting the police if they
 >DY> have any doubts at all about the legality of your behaviour.

Which, in most cases, will be completely unfounded. Those wrongly accused by
the staff at Boots should lodge a complaint with the appropriate professional
body for the photofinishing industry and, perhaps, even sue Boots for 
"derogatory and defamatory breach of copyright", pursuant to the Designs, 
Copyright and Patents Act 1988.

 PS> This is their duty, though.

But is it, though?  Their primary duty is defined in the contract they 
entered into with their customer -- to process the film correctly, to make 
the best prints possible from that film, and then to return that film and 
prints safely to the store for collection by the customer. There is also a 
legal obligation on them not to breach that customer's copyrights by 
producing multiple copies of any of the prints and, whilst many photofinishers
might tend to bash out one or two extra prints for their own interest, that
breach of copyright remains hidden.

What Boots did (and, it seems, are intent on doing) is not only in breach of 
their contractual obligations with their customers, but also in gross 
violation of their customers' copyrights. This latter may, itself, be an 
arrestable, criminal offence: s 107 of the C, D & P Act, 1988.

 PS> If they see pictures which might be described as paedophilic, then I 
 PS> hope they do phone the police. 

The imagination of their staff seems to have few bounds, for they are 
believed to have reported one person who photographed his baby son, mother-
naked and sprawled across a fluffy rug; whilst that photograph may arguably 
be more than a little distasteful and whilst it would certainly cause gross 
embarrassment to the chap in later life, there was obviously no paederastic 
intent to it.

 PS> It could stop people like Thomas Hamilton, the Dunblane killer.

Which, again, is twaddle; whilst it's true that Hamilton was a sick man, 
and that he liked to take photographs of boys under the age of 14 -- and
usually with them (at least! <grin>) wearing as few clothes as possible,
the press reports would seem to indicate that the victims of his unnatural 
interests were not quite naked -- they were wearing striped underpants,
supplied by Hamilton -- and so those photos would probably not have aroused
much suspicion.

Hamilton *should* have been stopped and, to a considerable extent, he was;
questions (rightly) began to be asked about the conduct of his "boys' club" 
after the mother of one of his young charges witnessed him using a wooden bat
to beat a boy across his bare skin.  If one cares to remember the reports 
correctly, one will recall that the causes of Hamilton's feelings of 
frustration were the result of his not being allowed to run his own, sick 
version of "scouting for boys"; that those feelings of frustration and 
rejection should culminated in the Dunblane massacre, could hardly have been
predicted by anyone.

Or should homosexualists be forbidden to join gun clubs?

Cheerio for now!
 
< Paul >

... Hard cases make bad laws; are *you* a hard case?    
--- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR]
 * Origin: Kneptune BBS (+44-161-777-8088) (2:250/109)