Slimelite BBS

Myra Hindley

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Tom Sulston · 1996-04-12 20:25 · #68770 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Myra Hindley by David Yates

And on the seventh day, David Yates came down from the mount. Bearing 2 stone tablets, upon which were these words. And they sayeth unto me:  "Myra Hindley"

 TS>> Ah, but who is more dangerous? Someone like Hindley, who is now safe to
 TS>> be released (I assume that her parole officer, since he'll be taking the
 TS>> blame if she kills again, is right),

 DY> I don't assume that her parole officer is right. He may have to take
 DY> the  blame professionally if he is wrong but others would have to suffer
 DY> much  worse consequences. Parole officers are not infallible, otherwise 
 DY> convicted criminals would never re-offend, and we know they do.

True, but what I'm saying is that he's certainly be the one in the best position to know. I mean, there's always the "what if" element.... Well, there's only one way to find out, isn't there? :)

 TS>> or someone that's
 TS>> only killed once, but is too unstable to be released?

 DY> Anybody who has killed should not be released if they are unstable.

Isn't that what I said? What I meant was that stable people should be released, since they can be useful to society.

 TS>> Personally, I don't think that anyone should be incarcerated for life,
 TS>> unless they would be a danger to society on their release.

 DY> I agree. This is why I don't want Myra Hindley released. What she did 
 DY> was evil beyond belief and I don't think we can be sure that anyone who
 DY> was once that evil, has since reformed. 

But would she be a danger? You're saying that she shouldn't be released because she might be. But what if she isn't dangerous anymore?

 TS>> I mean, if you're gonna lock 'em up forever, you might as well just
 TS>> execute 'em IMHO :-\ 

 DY> Not exactly. While they are alive in prison, they can be pardoned and 
 DY> released if it is later proved that they didn't commit the crimes they 
 DY> were convicted for, i.e. we avoid the Timothy Evans scenario.

True, but Hindley was proved guitly without any doubt, if you're not going to release her, why not do the decent thing and bump her off? 
   __________________
  /_  __/ __  /     /\  Fido: 2:252/330.42 or 2:250/410.17
  \/_/\/_____/_/_/_/ / rover@bix.empire.traffcom.co.uk
   \_\/\_____\_\_\_\/ tom.sulston@p17.pillarbox.fido.zetnet.co.uk

Function call to load WINDOWS/NT:  Sooooeee_pig_pig_pig_pig()

 >> Gothic Tag v1.04 <<


--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: From the land of the Dreaming Spires..... (2:252/330.42)