From Paul Dickie · 1996-04-12 03:03 · #68760 in AMIGA_NF
Greetings! I have just viewed the first part of Gulliver's Travels, shewn on Channel 4, on Sunday last; what an appallingly dreadful farrago it was! True, the actual scenes of Lemuel Gulliver in Lilluput and Brobdingnag were well enough contrived and staged, on a technical basis, but even there, the scriptwriter had made rather free use of the book; scenes were introduced that were quite absent from the original, whilst much of the original was wholly omitted. Whilst it *would* have been fair to have updated the language -- the original would seem much too courtly for most modern ears -- even that does not and cannot excuse the gross liberties taken with the text. I shall excuse the anachronism of the buckle at the back of Gulliver's waistcoat, for it is doubtful that the costumier(s) really had much idea of such matters; the waistcoat of Gulliver's son was correctly laced, though the cut of that waistcoat was just as faulty and just as out of period. I should have known what to expect of it, for the film *started* with some newly introduced flummery. This was the sub-plot, involving quite the worst violation of the work by the wholly needless introduction of the character of Dr John Bates; in the book, he was the doctor and surgeon to whom Gulliver was apprenticed and who died some nine years before the journey which, after being shipwrecked, on 5/11/1703, at approximately 30 W and 2 S, took Gulliver to Lilliput. However, in the film, Dr Bates became a Master in Lunacy, from which one may only suppose that the scriptwriter, Simon Moore, was indicating that Master Bates had indeed driven him to the very brink of madness! If such was the scriptwriter's confession, one must surely applaud his candour... o-) Perhaps it was felt that this crude sub-plot was needed to give the tale "relevance", or to spice it up for modern, jaded palettes, but the additions fit the original so ill that the whole looks like gold-work embroidery upon a ground of the coursest sack-cloth, or like a fine, Queen Anne commode being "married" to an MFI melamine video cabinet. Swift's excellent -- and, sad to say, still quite apt -- political satire was thus traduced and reduced in stature thereby. Surely, we *need* to be reminded of the idiocy of preferment by virtue of a person's ability in leaping and creeping, or of the folly of picking quarrels over something as trivial as which end of a boiled egg one should open. Are not the current disputes in Yugoslavia, or in Ulster, essentially as trivial in their origins? I am scarcely amazed that Simon Moore and the others involved in the production were so sympathetic to the Lilliputians, for they would surely be most at home amongst a race of scrabbling, scribbling little people whose mental and corporeal statures seem precisely matched! Cheerio for now! < Paul > ... I'm not opinionated, I'm always right! --- Blue Wave v2.12 [NR] * Origin: Kneptune BBS (+44-161-777-8088) (2:250/109)