Slimelite BBS

Murdered Children

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Tom Sulston · 1996-04-08 20:20 · #68713 in AMIGA_NF

In reply to Re: Murdered Children by Stuart Thompson

And on the seventh day, Stuart Thompson came down from the mount. Bearing 2 stone tablets, upon which were these words. And they sayeth unto me:  "Murdered Children"

 ST>>>  Why should we then now give Hindley the chance of freedom?

 TS>> AFAICS Hindley has been punished, I don't think that any punishment is
 TS>> enough for the willful taking of another's life, except for the fact
 TS>> that /she/ has to live with it for the rest of her life.  She poses no
 TS>> danger to society, according to her parole officer.

 ST>  What if her parole officer is wrong? Should we be willing to take that
 ST> chance?

Well, if anyone's to know her character and temperment, it'll be him, and also, it's his job on the line if it all goes wrong. Presumably he could just say "Sod it, her freedom isn't worth my job", but if he's willing t back up her appeal, he must be pretty damn sure.

 TS>> If you're gonna do something like the crimes that she and Brady
 TS>> perpetrated, you're not going to be put off by the punishment, just the
 TS>> htreat of capture. 

 ST>  So if she was released and decided to kill again the thought of
 ST> punishment wouldn't bother her?

That was a general comment, BTW. What I'm saying is that a druggie after money, for example, isn't going to choose to mug a little old lady rather than burgling a house because the sentence is 6 months shorter. The threat is that of actually being caught.

 TS>> And she /can/ be useful to society. And should be given that chance.

 ST>  I wonder how much use her victims would have been to society - Given
 ST> the chance.

Yes. I agree, but there's nothing anyone can do about the past. Two wrongs don't make a right. Surely if /something/ constructive can be salvaged from the whole situation, then it should.

 ST>>  I agree Tom. I have never condoned killing her IF she ever got out but
 ST>> I don't doubt for a minute it would happen.

 TS>> Her choice tho'. I mean, it's her risk.

 ST>  And its a risk we take that she won't re-offend again if we let her
 ST> out.

Yes, but as I said, her parole officer /should/ know.

 TS>>  ! Origin: From the land of the Dreaming Spires..... (2:252/330.42)

 ST>  Oxford??

Indeed, and you're the first to get it without a prod! :)

Mayby the Banbury addy gives it away! ;-)
   __________________
  /_  __/ __  /     /\  Fido: 2:252/330.42 or 2:250/410.17
  \/_/\/_____/_/_/_/ / rover@bix.empire.traffcom.co.uk
   \_\/\_____\_\_\_\/ tom.sulston@p17.pillarbox.fido.zetnet.co.uk

The Vogons are NOT the worst poets in the Galaxy, and I can prove it.

 >> Gothic Tag v1.04 <<


--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
 * Origin: From the land of the Dreaming Spires..... (2:252/330.42)