Slimelite BBS

DUNBLANE ATROCITY

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Paul Gardner · 1996-04-05 22:58 · #68612 in AMIGA_NF

Hi David,

You said this on 01 April 1996:

 PG> Unsettling as such scenes may be, they convey what happened far more
 PG> vividly than a press conference featuring a chief plod ever could.
 DY> I would settle for the chief plod. I think he would convey quite
 DY> enough.

You might, millions wouldn't. Let's put it another way; if people really
didn't want what you consider to be "intrusive" coverage, they would
boycott those newspapers and broadcasters. The classic case of a paper
misjudging the public mood was the Sun's Hillsborough coverage - the
resulting boycott hit them where it hurts most, in the pocket.

 PG> down on motorways when there has been an accident on the other side?
 PG> No matter what people /say/ about such things, they /love/ reading
 PG> about them - that's why sales and ratings go up at these times.
 DY> You have to consider the privacy of the people who are being featured
 DY> in these stories. Their lives are often made a misery.

Depends on the circumstances. If they have made the lives of many others
a misery (or perhaps caused extreme distress to just one person), they
have forfeited their privacy IMO, at least in the short term. So that
makes Jeremy Beadle fair game. <g>

 IMO the press
 DY> should not be allowed to run stories which intrude into the private
 DY> lives of individuals where there is no public interest served. In other
 DY> words, I would like to see a right to privacy.

Sounds reasonable enough in theory but it's not so simple in practice.
Given the vagaries of our archaic legal system, I can tell you for starters
that the mass of ordinary, decent folk won't get a look in. 

No, the people who would benefit from a privacy law would have been the
likes of Robert Maxwell, Peter Clowes, Darius Guppy and the chairmen
of privatised utilities. In Maxwell's case, his suspicious activities 
were widely known in the world of journalism but nobody could touch him
because he served writ after writ after writ whenever anyone got anywhere
near the truth. And that was with the /existing/ legislation, which is
very good at protecting the rich, powerful and corrupt, but hopeless for
defending the poor and innocent. Imagine how Maxwell and the rest would
claim their "privacy" was being violated whenever someone tried to find
the truth behind their shadowy activities. 

 DY> About a decade ago, a family which I know well, were "exposed" by the
 DY> tabloid press in a very famous case which I'm sure you would remember
 DY> if I recounted the details, which I won't. They were targeted by the
 DY> tabloids on and off for several years. The case concerned their private
 DY> lives which the tabloids found interesting and unusual. There was
 DY> absolutely no public interest served in publicising their private
 DY> lives. Their lives were made an absolute misery by the press.

Ah yes, some people do like to blur the distinction between "the public
interest" and "what the public is interested in", don't they?

If this family happened to be the victims in the Ealing vicarage rape 
case, I wouldn't be surprised that you felt that way. That kind of 
salacious reporting gave the industry a very bad name and led to major 
changes in the coverage of rape cases.

In the case of public figures, the situation is more complicated. When
an MP stands on a platform of "family values" and parades his family to
get himself elected, I would have no qualms about "outing" them. These
people are in a position of power over the rest of us; we have a right to
expect them to live by the rules that they make for us. However, no
public interest is served by revealing that someone like Frank Bough
visits prostitutes IMO.

 DY> were dying and nobody was helping them. OTOH at Dunblane there was
 DY> nothing that anyone could have done which which was not already being
 DY> done when the footage was shot. The Dunblane footage satisfied the
 DY> rubbernecks and nothing more.

I'm not so sure. Just about every normal person shared in those people's
grief. 

 PG> It does have its lighter moments, though. A story came in from
 PG> America a while back about a bloke who had elephantosis of the

Sorry, got that wrong. It was Australia, not America. ;-)

 PG> gonads. I kid  you not. It was just like the Viz character Buster
 PG> Gonad, who carted his bits around in a wheelbarrow, except that this
 PG> guy could have done with a pickup truck. We didn't run the story, for
 PG> some reason.
 DY> Ouch!
 DY> I can't stand reading Buster Gonad. It brings tears to my eyes every
 DY> time. :)

Remember the one where he paints them like giant Easter eggs and the
mayor breaks them with a big mallet for the kiddies? Oh, my poor plums. ;-)


Bye,
 
Paul  (paul.gardner@mcr1.poptel.org.uk)

-+- OLMS 2.53p UNREG
---
 * Origin: ATTiTuDE! ... A BiT GiNGeR PRoDucTIon... 0181 204 0891 (2:254/400)