From Peter Marsh · 1996-04-04 05:52 · #68579 in AMIGA_NF
KD> I think you've overlooked something - I don't care. KWK> It's actually quite common for thieves to feel no remorse so your lack KWK> of conscience regarding the theft of software comes as no real surprise. Fun thread, so do you ever copy videos? photocopy out of books ? thats exactly the same as copying computer software. I think some people have been misusing analogies. Someone compared "stealing software" to stealing a car. Not very accurate, since what you are doing is COPYING software. You don't COPY a car, you TAKE it. Worlds of difference. Now, an appropriate analogy would be COPYING a book. I decide not to TAKE the book, I am not physically carting *it* away. I COPY it, by whatever method (hand copy, photo copy, eidetic memory) and then take the medium upon which i have placed the copy. This is not only an appropriate analogy, it is accurate (go ahead and poke a whole in it without looking stupid in front of the world). OK, so book publishers may not like it if you photocopy their book instead of buying it, BUT you do have a legal ability to make that single copy. That's how most material in Universities I attended was distributed. You may make a copy for yourself or you may purchase it. What you do not have legal protection to do is make mass copies and then sell them, or in certain instances depending on content and quantity, give them away. Only the publisher can choose to distribute on such a wide scale. Even then, it is copy right infringement, it is NOT defined as stealing (this is getting into simantics [sp?] but it is in fact not defined as stealing). COPYING software amounts to the same thing, largely because software PUBLISHERS are covered in the same legal way as book publishers. Another perfect analogy is video tapes. Come on, how many of you anti-pirating prudes, who think little Billy giving his friend the latest game is a menace to society, have copies of movies at home, or of television shows, even of commercials. I mean COPIES, not something you purchased from a vido store. I suspect that many people have these. It is technically illegal to own a copy, but ya wanna know something? If you own ONE COPY for your personal use, they are NOT going to come down on you for anything. Who would? No one cares! Not even movie studios. What they DO care about are the individuals who make MANY COPIES and SELL them. That is known as video pirating (owning one copy is not). Sound familiar? I have advice for you shareware writers, if you dont want to feel cheated by people not paying you for your software, do NOT release it. Problem solved. If i don't know it's there, i won't miss it. I will close this too long post with one final comment. Kevin, If you ever write a shareware program I will store it on my HD indefinitely. And I am not going to pay you for it. Feel free to netmail me any flames you may have, but keep in mind i'll probably never get to read it and of course the fact I don't care about your oppinions either way. Not because I am narrow minded but because i simply - do not care -. Peter Marsh - Sysop of NO LiMiTS BBS (01)293 413668 Fido: 2:440/303.0 For quick response email: an536039@anon.penet.fi Find me on IRC #warez .. The Internet: Home shop lifting network! --- Xenolink 1.981, XEmacs 1.2 * Origin: No Limits BBS (2:440/303)