Slimelite BBS

DUNBLANE ATROCITY

Back to AMIGA_NF

From David Yates · 1996-04-01 22:04 · #68554 in AMIGA_NF

Quoting PAUL GARDNER to DAVID YATES on 04-01-96 01:14 on the subject of 
DUNBLANE ATROCITY

PG> DY> carnage. How do these journalists sleep at night?
PG> PG> What sort of person watches and listens to these things?
PG> DY> I watched the coverage because I wanted to find out what
PG> DY> happened. The TV companies could easily have told me what had
PG> DY> happened without interviewing child witnesses and filming
PG> DY> terrified mothers. 

PG>Unsettling as such scenes may be, they convey what happened far more
PG>vividly than a press conference featuring a chief plod ever could.

I would settle for the chief plod. I think he would convey quite enough.

PG>AFAIK no footage of witnesses would have been used without consent
PG>(and the  parents' consent in the case of children).

In the case of the children who were interviewed, I would expect that 
the parents did give their consent. In the case of the mothers rushing 
to the scene, I doubt that consent was sought, TICBW.

PG>Quite frankly, if journalism has become too "intrusive", it's because
PG>we are a nation of rubbernecks - why do you think the traffic slows
PG>down on motorways when there has been an accident on the other side?
PG>No matter what people /say/ about such things, they /love/ reading
PG>about them - that's why sales and ratings go up at these times.

You have to consider the privacy of the people who are being featured in 
these stories. Their lives are often made a misery. IMO the press should 
not be allowed to run stories which intrude into the private lives of 
individuals where there is no public interest served. In other words, I 
would like to see a right to privacy.

About a decade ago, a family which I know well, were "exposed" by the 
tabloid press in a very famous case which I'm sure you would remember if 
I recounted the details, which I won't. They were targeted by the 
tabloids on and off for several years. The case concerned their private 
lives which the tabloids found interesting and unusual. There was 
absolutely no public interest served in publicising their private lives. 
Their lives were made an absolute misery by the press.

PG> PG> The coverage
PG> PG> of Dunblane /was/ upsetting - it was meant to be. Do you
PG> PG> honestly believe it could have been done any other way? If so,
PG>how?  DY> They could have reported the facts without intruding into
PG> DY> the grief of individuals. They could have had the decency not to
PG> DY> film people who were in a state of shock and panic.

PG>Did you feel the same way about Michael Buerk's report of the
PG>Ethiopian famine in 1984? Would a map of the drought region - without
PG>showing the human side of it - really have affected so many people
PG>that it triggered the whole Live Aid saga? Of course not. 

That's a very good point which I must admit has made me think. Very 
often journalists serve a very definite public interest by filming an 
atrocity like a famine. The reports there showed the world that people 
were dying and nobody was helping them. OTOH at Dunblane there was 
nothing that anyone could have done which which was not already being 
done when the footage was shot. The Dunblane footage satisfied the 
rubbernecks and nothing more. The footage from Ethiopia showed a problem 
in need of a solution.

PG>It does have its lighter moments, though. A story came in from
PG>America a while back about a bloke who had elephantosis of the
PG>gonads. I kid  you not. It was just like the Viz character Buster
PG>Gonad, who carted his bits around in a wheelbarrow, except that this
PG>guy could have done with a pickup truck. We didn't run the story, for
PG>some reason. 

Ouch! 

I can't stand reading Buster Gonad. It brings tears to my eyes every 
time. :)

david@yates.dungeon.com
04/01/96
---
* CMPQwk #1.4* UNREGISTERED EVALUATION COPY

--- WILDMAIL!/WC v4.12 
 * Origin: Ooh! LONDON [LiveChat-MultiLines] 0181-395-3108  (2:254/233.0)