From Tom Sulston · 1996-04-02 21:08 · #68537 in AMIGA_NF
And on the seventh day, Stuart Thompson came down from the mount. Bearing 2 stone tablets, upon which were these words. And they sayeth unto me: "Murdered Children"
ST>> Why should we then now give Hindley the chance of freedom?
TS>> Is there not a chance that she may do something useful with her life,
TS>> now? I mean, I don't think that anyone of your generation would forgive
TS>> her for her horrific crimes, but surely giving her the change to do
TS>> something constructive, rather than just rotting in prison...
ST> Did she give the children she murdered a chance to do something
ST> constructive with their lives? NO.
ST> IMHO she has forfeited ANY right to do anything again EXCEPT rot in
ST> prison.
OK, but why waste /another/ life, when something good can be done with it. I don't mean for her, but for society. Surely the purpose of the prison system is to:
1. Punish the criminal.
2. Protect society.
3. Act as a deterrent.
4. Enable criminals to become useful to society.
AFAICS Hindley has been punished, I don't think that any punishment is enough for the willful taking of another's life, except for the fact that /she/ has to live with it for the rest of her life.
She poses no danger to society, according to her parole officer.
If you're gonna do something like the crimes that she and Brady perpetrated, you're not going to be put off by the punishment, just the htreat of capture.
And she /can/ be useful to society. And should be given that chance.
ST>> Hindley has never tried to expalin her actions..because she never can.
ST>> Brady probably did ther best thing by declaring insanity.
TS>> Brady was hanged, yes? Why not Hindley?
ST> No Tom, Brady was not hanged. He was sentenced to life as well but in
ST> Broadmoor
ST> where he still resides if my facts are correct ( forgive me if he has
ST> been moved).
Ah right, sorry 'bout that. I thought he was.....
ST>> She will NEVER be a reformed character. She is evil through and
ST>> through.
TS>> I'm afraid I don't believe this. I reckon that there is good in
TS>> everybody, and she should be given the opportunity to to show this.
ST> She never gave the children she murdered that opportunity.
No, but is denying her it going to change that?
ST>> If by any remote fluke she was ever allowed out. I would give her a
ST>> lifespan
ST>> of about a month before any one of about a dozen names I could mention
ST>> killed her.
TS>> But surely then they would be just as bad as she? (Well, perhaps not
TS>> /that/ bad, but you get my point)
ST> I agree Tom. I have never condoned killing her IF she ever got out but
ST> I don't doubt for a minute it would happen.
Her choice tho'. I mean, it's her risk.
TS>> Christian philosophy, surely forgivness is one of the most important
TS>> tenets of this way of thinking?
ST> You are possibly right Tom but I am afraid I can NEVER and will NEVER
ST> forgive her for what she did.
I understand why, and know that a lot of people feel the same way. But surely the sign of a civilised society is one that is able to put all of its members to good use, for its own good.
__________________
/_ __/ __ / /\ Fido: 2:252/330.42 or 2:250/410.17
\/_/\/_____/_/_/_/ / rover@bix.empire.traffcom.co.uk
\_\/\_____\_\_\_\/ tom.sulston@p17.pillarbox.fido.zetnet.co.uk
He does the work of three men: Moe, Larry, and Curly.
>> Gothic Tag v1.04 <<
--- Spot 1.3a Unregistered
* Origin: From the land of the Dreaming Spires..... (2:252/330.42)