Slimelite BBS

DUNBLANE ATROCITY

Back to AMIGA_NF

From Paul Gardner · 1996-04-01 07:14 · #68490 in AMIGA_NF

Hi David,

You said this on 27 March 1996:

 DY> carnage. How do these journalists sleep at night?
 PG> What sort of person watches and listens to these things?
 DY> I watched the coverage because I wanted to find out what happened. The
 DY> TV companies could easily have told me what had happened without
 DY> interviewing child witnesses and filming terrified mothers.

Unsettling as such scenes may be, they convey what happened far more
vividly than a press conference featuring a chief plod ever could. AFAIK
no footage of witnesses would have been used without consent (and the 
parents' consent in the case of children).

Journalists often get flak at the scenes of tragic events - ironically,
this flak usually comes from rubbernecks. At one road accident scene, a
photographer that I know was accosted by a rubberneck for being a 
"parasite". My friend turned round and said: "It's my job to be here - 
what's /your/ excuse?" Mr Rubberneck had nothing further to say.

Quite frankly, if journalism has become too "intrusive", it's because we
are a nation of rubbernecks - why do you think the traffic slows down on
motorways when there has been an accident on the other side? No matter
what people /say/ about such things, they /love/ reading about them
- that's why sales and ratings go up at these times.

 PG> The coverage
 PG> of Dunblane /was/ upsetting - it was meant to be. Do you honestly
 PG> believe it could have been done any other way? If so, how?
 DY> They could have reported the facts without intruding into the grief of
 DY> individuals. They could have had the decency not to film people who
 DY> were in a state of shock and panic.

Did you feel the same way about Michael Buerk's report of the Ethiopian
famine in 1984? Would a map of the drought region - without showing the
human side of it - really have affected so many people that it triggered
the whole Live Aid saga? Of course not. 

Anyway, let's thank heaven for small mercies. At least caring Princess
Di didn't come on a photocall.

 DY> They certainly should have had the
 DY> decency not to interview children walking away from the scene of the
 DY> carnage and obviously in need of counselling.

You'd be amazed at what hits the cutting room floor. When I do shifts
for one TV company, some of the international stuff is truly shocking,
especially war footage. Most of these are for the Asian market, where 
they apparently demand to see all the gory details - severed limbs,
burned flesh, you name it. All in the best possible taste.

It does have its lighter moments, though. A story came in from America
a while back about a bloke who had elephantosis of the gonads. I kid 
you not. It was just like the Viz character Buster Gonad, who carted his
bits around in a wheelbarrow, except that this guy could have done with
a pickup truck. We didn't run the story, for some reason.


Bye,
 
Paul  (paul.gardner@mcr1.poptel.org.uk)


... Witness the firepower of this fully armed and operational tagline!
/// IMHO V1.07

-+- OLMS 2.53p UNREG
---
 * Origin: ATTiTuDE! ... A BiT GiNGeR PRoDucTIon... 0181 204 0891 (2:254/400)