From Neil Harrison · 1996-04-07 16:26 · #68193 in COMMON-ROOM
Scully, I've finally got proof! It's all in this report from 28 Mar 96 Mulder, it's just a message from Philip
No Scully, thats what they want you to believe! Here read it.
Hi Philip,
PD> The Secrets Of the X-Files video
[spoiler lines nicked :)]
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> ||
PD> \/
PD> In the vid it shows Mulder as a kid being in the same room as his
PD> sister when she is abducted, whereas in the series he explains that
PD> under regression hypnosis he was in his bedroom and was paralysed. So
PD> what really happened? was he in the same room or in his bedroom?
You're not wrong, and this has been discussed before in here, although not relating to TSOTXF vid.
The bit on the vid is also taken from the series but, obviously a different episode to the one you're taking about.
In actual fact, AFAIK, all the scenes in TSOTXF are from series 1 and 2.
One of the reason mooted in here was, IIRC, that it just goes to show the inacuracies of regression hypnosis.
Another possibility is that Mulder couldn't remember exactly what happened until he'd undergone regression hypnosis so filled in some blanks himself (as best he ould figure them out).
There you go, two proposals equally arguing the pro's and con's of regression hypnosis :)
All done, bye bye.
Neil
England
... Mulder: Before anyone passes judgement, may I remind you, we are in the arctic.
Ice (#1X07)
--- Spot 1.3a #1059
* Origin: Near Ellens Air Base, Southwest Idaho (2:250/366.7)