From Stuart Presnell · 1996-04-14 23:13 · #65589 in HAM
Hello All!
I just watched today's episode of Voyager (can't remember the title - Kazon, a
transporter, Chakotay the hero), and I just had to say something!
This message partly deals with my hatred for Cpt Janeway, so if you think she's great, and won't hear a word against her, move to the next message (and reply
to it!)
First - was she so blinded with hope that the beacon might be from home that her reasoning powers evaporated? "Who else could be sending that message?" she asks. Well, how about one of the people you've hailed over the past few months? Couldn't one of them have taken the Federation identifier and used it as a trap, for example? Or, for that matter, the traitor Seska, whom everyone seems to have forgotten about.. oh, look at that, so it was!
Chakotay had the right idea - this might be a trap, so don't beam the beacon aboard. So what does Janeway do? Moves into tractor range and locks onto the beacon instead. Well done - couldn't have sent in a probe at all, could you?
So the Kazon attack, and in defence Voyager rotates shield frequencies. Why can't they just randomise them, so no-one could predict what would come next (which is evidently what Seska was doing)
Voyager's systems must be more user-friendly than Windows! These Kazon, who don't have transporter technology, rush into the transporter room, steal a component, and then beam out! Must have big, idiot-proof buttons. "To escape with stolen hardware, press this button".
And if the Kazon could just break off the tractor beam on their ship, why did they hang around to gloat? Why not just cast away and Warp off? Voyager couldn't follow with a shuttle sticking out of its guts. Their plan wasn't to lure Chakotay in - they just wanted the transporter.
Chakotay and Torres consider how to get the component back - and their best idea is to use a plan Seska thought of herself. Does this seem right? To outwit Seska, they mean to use an idea she knows very well, and possibly knows how to counteract?
Chakotay cruises in toward the Kazon ship (which either isn't as fast as a shuttle, or they aren't in any hurry), shuts off all power, and then coasts in next to the vessel. Don't the Kazon have sensors sensitive enough to detect a hulking great object wandering up to their hull? Seems a bit dumb.
Chakotay beams onto the ship from the shuttle - meaning that Voyager had at least one transporter independant of the main systems. Yet when the Kazon were scarpering with the stolen component, and Voyager's systems were down, someone (Kim or Paris, I think) said that transporting the tihng wasn't an option. Bet he's kicking himself now!
When Chakotay reveals himself to be on the Kazon ship, he phasers the transporter component, strolls up to Seska, and hands her the phaser! Am I being thick, or could he have just beamed back to the shuttle instead, and fled? Meeting old friends is fine enough, but there's a time and a place for everything!
Actually, I'll be honest - for a moment, I honestly thought Chakotay might have defected as well. I thought "Bloody hell, that's briliant" when I saw him give her the phaser. "He's gone to join the Kazon and to be with Seska! Excellent!" I retracted that thought when I realised that it would mean the loss of the only competent officer on Voyager, and slumped when I saw him being beaten up in a very non-"welcome to the Dark Side" kinda way.
"I didn't want anyone to get hurt" says Seska to Chakotay, while he bleeds from his forehead (and before he is beaten up by the Maj).
Is it my imagination, or does Chakotay turn into The Godfather when beaten up?
A minor point, but I'll note it anyway :) When Chakotay, under the influence, says that Seska will kill the Maj, she says very quickly "He's delirious, he doesn't know what he's saying" (OWTTE). This seemed to me to be a very desparate act, and a bit of a giveaway. I would have thought she would be more professional than that, from the way Chakotay and Torres talk about her.
Whah?! I can't believe Janeway actually bought that BS from Torres about "the morale on the ship"! All her worries about "not affecting the balance of power in the quadrant", and "not letting Federation technology fall into alien hands" suddenly go out the window (a dangerous thing when you're in space! :) Whaddya think was the effect on the morale when she blew up the only way to get home, to stop the Kazon from having it, ("Caretaker"), or refused to use the Supertransporter to avoid interfering with an alien race ("Prime Factors")?
WTF is Torres talking about? Is she a compulsive liar, or just trying to impress the Captain? Everyone else knows that you can't beam between a warping vessel and a static one, but she still pulls off the bluff that "she's done it before".
[NB: I honestly just switched on the Radio - UK Top 40, about 4:33 pm - and heard "You stupid girl/ Can't believe you fake it". Synchronicity at play.]
Let's get this straight - Voyager is at Warp. Paris says 60 seconds to transporter range. About 20 seconds later, Torres is scanning the ship to find Chakotay, and finds a dampening field, which is 2m in diameter, we learn later. 40 seconds even at Warp 1, is 12 million km (plus transporter range of 40,000 km, but that doesn't add much to it). So at 12 million km, Torres can detect a 2m field - /and/ thinks she can isolate a single lifeform amongst an entire ship!
This is even more amazing when you consider that, when Voyager was close enough to see the faces of two Kazon drifting in space, Kim couldn't even identify them as being organic, let alone Kazon bodies - just "debris from the ship".
I did notice that they beamed through the shields, not once but twice! Either that, or dropped the shields (twice) while under heavy Kazon fire.
Those Kazon weapons must have had a lucky shot. Within about 60 seconds, the shields drop from 23% to 16%, but they're fine after that! Maybe the Kazon just stopped to let Voyager get its breath back?
Er, when they beam back the Kazon to their ship, won't those three guys kill the Maj of the Nistrom? Doesn't that constitute a "shift in the balance of power between the sects?"
Chakotay comes home, safe and well, having stopped the Kazon from obtaining Federation technology. Does Janeway say "Well done, but you should have asked first?" No, she kicks him in the... ..in the Ready Room, and says "You must never do that again, you naughty little boy!" I was cheering for him to punch her out, but he controlled himself. He could at least have pointed out that if he hadn't gone to get it, the Kazon would be away scot free by now, and fighting a civil war. Janeway certainly wouldn't have been able to stop them, with a crippled ship.
Compare her reaction with other another Captain's:
TNG:"Redemption II". Data diobeys orders while in command of his own ship, because he thinks he's spotted some Romulans. Does Picard make him apologise, and tell him off for 2 minutes? No, he congratulates his success, justifies his actions, and then mentions that Data was a bit naughty.
A couple more things I noticed after the show - did they ever go back for that phaser Chakotay left behind, or did they give it to the Kazon as a souvenir?
And how did they fix up that little hole, in the end? One minute there's a shuttle through the hull, the next, patched up and no more problem. And did they take a look at the shuttle to learn about Kazon technology? Did anyone think of that?
I have a feeling there are a few more points I've missed, but I'll stop here! 8)
... "That's all you Kazon think of, sects, sects, sects".
SmP
--- GEcho 1.00
* Origin: SmP's Point off Pacific Lightning BBS (2:440/7.46)