Slimelite BBS

Timber!

Back to HAM

From Stephen Liddell · 1996-04-14 15:39 · #65577 in HAM

Hi Steven,

-=> Quoting Steven Winetrobe to Paul Gardner <=-

 PG> BTW am I the only one to think Tuvok makes a terrible
 PG> Vulcan? He's so wooden, I'm surprised the Voyager crew don't
 PG> get splinters when they touch him.
 SP> Not that I disagree, but Tuvok is how a Vulcan is supposed to be,

 SW>  My 2p worth  <G>
 SW>  Most people think of Spock when they think of VULCANS.
 SW>  But Spock was not a run of the mill Vulcan.. He was half Human and
 SW>  that made his character abit more complex and interesting.
 SW>  TUVOK is a 100% Vulcan....LOGICAL, Suppressed emotions etc......
 SW>  This means therefore that he will not be as interesting as the other
 SW>  EMOTIONAL characters......

 SW>  Have you ever met a Normal INTERSTING VULCAN ????

What about Sarek?  Anyway, Vulcans are not mean't to be interesting,
that is why Spock was half human so they could have a bit of drama.

 SW>  Even Spocks dady was a bit of a rebel.. marrying a HUMAN FEMALE !!
Ok, maybe not Sarek then.  I think the problem with Tuvok (if there is one)
is that he tries to be too Vulcan as if all a Vulcan can be is logical.
That is plainly wrong.  People like Spock, Sarek, Saavik and even
Valeris are logical but they don't keep showing just the one side of
their character.  Tuvok has nothing in the way of character traits.  He
does not enjoy debating or arguing, he does not get "irratated", he
doesn't seem to have any motives or traits at all.  It would be like
having a Klingon do nothing except talk about honour.  Lets get back some
of the Vulcan mysticism and even the neck pinches, mind melds and telepathy
and stop treating Tuvok like an ordinary human and a boring one at that.

Having said that I like Tuvok.

 SW>   Thus endeth my 2p's worth....

Good, I'd give real money if he'd shut up.

Stephen Liddell
Temporarily trapped in 13thC Persia with 600,000 Mongols and lots of humerous anecdotes.

 * AmyBW v2.13 *
... I don't agree with you at all Mr Spock.Thats not unusual Dr.-The Apple
--- MDTA 2.2
 * Origin: Sigma Gold Online 24Hrs 01923-443741 (2:257/128.0)