Slimelite BBS

Picard 10, Kirk 0

Back to HAM

From Stephen Liddell · 1996-04-14 14:44 · #65572 in HAM

Hi Stuart,

-=> Quoting Stuart Presnell to Robin Clay <=-

 SP> 03 Apr 96 23:36, Robin Clay wrote to All in the PUNCH Echo:

 SP> And I thought I'd respond to it.  Come on, let's start up a "Who's the
 SP> Best" war again!

Ok, its always good fun and this time we have 3 Captains who aren't as
good as Kirk instead of just 2 ;-)

By missing out No.10 does not mean I concede the issue, I just didn't know
whether you meant Wesley or Q.

 RC> 9.  Kirk's doctor takes care of the physical and mental
 RC> well-being of the crew, and Kirk would never have a Counselor.
 RC> (Captain, I sense hostility from the Romulan commander from whom
 RC> you stole the cloaking device.) Picard always has conflicting
 RC> advice from his doctor and counselor.

 SP> Let's put it to the vote.  Who would you rather spend a one-hour
 SP> session with: Troi and Beverly, or McCoy?

Now that really does depend doesn't it but if you were really ill you
wouldn't visit any of the first two.

 RC> 8.  Kirk took a cloaking device from the Romulans. Picard gave a
 RC> cloaking device back to the Romulans.

 SP> Kirk had a cloaking device and never used it.  Picard had a cloaking
 SP> device, escaped from an asteroid with it, and then de-cloaked in front
 SP> of the Romulans to impress them.

Au contraire mon Capitan!  Kirk infiltrated a Romulan battle fleet, stole
the device and used it to escape from Romulan Space.  Picard was frightened
to use the device and proberly wouldn't have if it wasn't for Riker & co.


 RC> 7.  Picard's Kobashi Maru test: "Romulans, this is Captain
 RC> Picard. We are here to save the crew of the Kobashi Maru -+-"
 RC> <BOOM> "Cadet Picard, that is the all-time low for the Kobashi
 RC> Maru Senario..." Kirk just happens to be the ONLY person EVER in
 RC> the History in the Great Big Federation to beat the thing, thanks
 RC> to his mastery of all things computerized.

 SP> Kirk had to cheat to pass his exams.  Picard lazed around the Academy,
 SP> carved his initials into trees, played sports, and still managed to
 SP> graduate.

It was cheating, it was changing the rules of the test :-)  Besides, Starfleet
are hardly going to fail someone for that especially if they have an idea of
how good he might be, it wasn't even a proper exam.  You mean Picard wasted
his time, failed exams and got distracted by his girlfriends.  Doesn't it
show how single minded Kirk can be if he of all people avoids that problem
at the academy?

 RC> 6.  Kirk can count; he never called Spock Number One (he's second
 RC> in rank, obviously). Picard obviously flunked basic algebra.

 SP> Riker is FIRST officer.  Hence, Picard calles him Number One.  (I
 SP> wonder why he never calls Data a Number Two... ;)
 SP> Kirk, OTOH, called Spock "a half-breed", amongst other things. 
 SP> Charmer. 

It would be wierd if Picard called everyone by their number. "Ensign 907
go to Engineering with No. 4 and die in a plasma conduit".  The half breed
shows just how good friends Kirk and Spock were  that Spock could forget
about it, afterall if it wasn't logical Spock would have said so.

 RC> 5.  Kirk would have beaten Q at his own game, a la Trelaine, and
 RC> then called up the Q-continum to take him home. (He probably
 RC> would have BEATEN Q to a bloody pulp, or at least knocked him out
 RC> a la Sisko <DS9 PLUG!>> :)

 SP> Kirk pops Q on the nose.
 SP> Q: "As I thought, you /are/ a savage race."
 SP> <THWICK!  As all human race disappears>

Perhaps if Picard had stood up for himself in the beginning he wouldn't
have been pestered by Q for 7 years.

 RC> 4.  Kirk could have made Lore self-destruct in 5 minutes. (i.e.
 RC> People are irrational. They must be destroyed. You have feelings.
 RC> You must be a person. You must be destroyed. <BOOM> Scotty, send
 RC> a crew up here to clean this mess.

 SP> Kirk was pitted against dumbass computers.  Lore is more intelligent
 SP> than all of Kirk's crew put together.

Oooh.  That was a bit below the belt <g>

 SP> Lore:  Yeah, sure they're irrational.  By why must they be destroyed? 
 SP> Get outta here, baldy!  <THWAM!>

Hey, there are a lot of Picard fans who just won't appreciate people
putting down Picard.

 RC> 3.  Kirk invented a card game, fizzbin. Picard won't even play
 RC> poker.

 SP> Kirk just made up a few dumb rules for a card game.  Picard invented a
 SP> manouver.
 SP> And Picard /does/ play poker.

Whooh, inventing a manuevre, big man.  Kirk did so many heroic deeds, he sounds
like he got bored of doing it in ST:6 when they once again save civilisation
as we know it.

 RC> 2.  Best character on Picard's ship, Riker, a wannna-be Kirk.
 RC> (Descendant?)

 SP> Best character on Kirk's ship?  Spock, a wanna-be Data.  :)

:-)

 RC> 1.  Something brings them together to fight to the death. Picard
 RC> says, "Let's talk this over/Get in touch with our feelings/etc."
 RC> Kirk shoots him on the spot.

 SP> Kirk always goes for the "shoot first, ask questions later" approach.

 SP> Example -
 SP> Kirk:  "You wan't to fight, eh?  OKay, take that!"
 SP>   Kirk, Shakka, when the walls fell.

I don't quite know how to answer that, still this should get me a few flames.
There are some Sisko and Janeway lists too somewhere.  In two weeks time you'll
probably regret starting this as we all fragment into the various "Captain"
camps. :-)

Stephen Liddell
Temporarily trapped in 13thC Persia with 600,000 Mongols and lots of humerous anecdotes.

 * AmyBW v2.13 *
... I said talk with her... not fight with her -Kirk, Elaan of Troyus
--- MDTA 2.2
 * Origin: Sigma Gold Online 24Hrs 01923-443741 (2:257/128.0)