From Stuart Presnell · 1996-04-07 04:20 · #65472 in HAM
In reply to Klingons by Barry Richards
Hello Barry! 30 Mar 96 17:51, Barry Richards wrote to Mark Stevens: BR> If the whole race was intent on fighting, to protect BR> their honour. Who would they get to be farmers to grow food, have BR> you ever seen a Klingon accountant or Solicitor,Bank manager, Everyone seems to have a terribly one-sided view of the Klingons. Just because we only see the "honour and glory" side of their culture, we assume that's all there is to them. We've never really seen any other aspect of their culture - the day to day life tey must have, for their society to operate - but that's no reason to assume it doesn't exist. We've never seen anyone in the Federation writing a novel, or building a starship, but we know it must happen. In the Klingon culture "honour" is not the same as "glory", as so many people seem to think. To go out and kill your enemies, or claim a planet in the name of the Klingon Empire, brings "glory". But to be honest and fair, to treat people with respect where it is due, to be true to your word - these bring "honour". Honour can be achieved by any man, whatever his honest trade. This is why the Klingon way of life is, in many ways, superior to our own. By their standard, it is better to be honest than to be successful. ["House of Quark"] BR> The previous head of the particular family was cheated out of his money BR> and land by another equally dishonest Klingon. As I recall, (and I don't remember the episode very well), the inheritance of the family name was taken by an outsider, because the House could not be taken by a female (the only rightful descendant surviving). BR> But that makes no sense, because a Klingon warrior would not cheat, BR> because it has 'no honour' to do so. Now you are assuming that all Klingons fit the stereotype. Does every human aim for power and success? Is /every/ Ferengi devoted to amassing wealth? Similarly, not every Klingon is ultimately devoted to maintaining honour. BR> There are so many contradictions to the Klingon way that I do not think it BR> possible to have such a system, based on combat and honour. Their system based on honour seems to work a lot better (in terms of people working with people) than ours - they are devoted to honesty, where we are all fighting to get to the top of the heap. The combat side of their culture seems mainly to be in order to reslove arguments - we have lawyers, they have batleths! Which would you prefer...? SmP --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: SmP's Point off Pacific Lightning BBS (2:440/7.46)