From Stuart Presnell · 1996-04-07 03:49 · #65468 in HAM
Hello Thomas! 27 Mar 96 19:02, Thomas Morley wrote to Stuart Presnell: [That darned Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle] SP>> The best method I can think of (ATM) to get around this SP>> problem is to somehow measure the nature of each particle as SP>> it is converted. If some kind of graduated force field (eg SP>> electromagnetic) could be put in place around the subject, SP>> each particle's postion in the field could be measured by SP>> the magnitude of the field. Perhaps three perpendicular fields could be SP>> used, which would give the three-dimensional position of the particle. TM> The problem is, this amount of energy [required to observe a particle] TM> is sufficient to alter the energy (and thus the velocity) of the particle: If 3 perpendicular graded fields are established around a subject, and the magnitude of each field affects each particle in some way, then when the particle is converted (which is not neccesarily the same as observing it), that effect might be incorporated into the photon produced. Any effect upon the particle is in place before the conversion takes place. SP>> Now, since the particle will also be moving, it's component in SP>> each field will change (since the conversion into energy SP>> will take finite time). If this change can be measured, the SP>> velocity of the particle can also be measured. TM> A similar problem occurs measuring the energy: I don't think we are measuring the energy itself. The internal energy of the particle is incorporated ionto the resultant photon. We are measuring the component of velocity in each direction. I think this can be labelled, as below, without changing it randomly (which is the problem you describe). TM> it takes one Quantum to measure the energy of the particle, but that TM> Quantum is sufficient to disturb the position of the particle in an TM> uncertain way; Is there no conceivable difference between labelling something and measuring it? SmP --- GEcho 1.00 * Origin: SmP's Point off Pacific Lightning BBS (2:440/7.46)